History
Source provenance and corroboration
- 1.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Explain one reason the audience of A matters.
[2 marks] · no calculator - 2.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Why does B not provide independent corroboration of A?
[2 marks] · no calculator - 3.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Explain what C can and cannot establish about the manager's claim.
[3 marks] · no calculator - 4.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Explain why absence of injury entries in a surviving mill ledger would not necessarily prove safety.
[3 marks] · no calculator - 5.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Assess whether A should be discarded because it has a reputational interest.
[4 marks] · no calculator - 6.
Entirely fictional archive for source skills, not a real event. In the invented town of Mere, a fictional 1905 petition demands safer mills. A: a mill manager's letter to investors says, 'No serious injury occurred this month.' B: a newspaper repeats A verbatim, naming the manager as its source. C: a hospital register records a mill worker's broken arm but does not state how it happened. All documents and attributions are invented. Design a corroboration strategy for investigating the petition's safety demands.
[4 marks] · no calculator
Marking points are indicative, not an official mark scheme. Accept equivalent valid methods and supported interpretations that address the task; award each mark once without requiring the model wording.