IB · BM HL

Business Management HL

Operations management (HL): decision trees and critical path analysis — Unit 5 HL

Name: ____________________Date: November 19, 2026
  1. 1.

    Option A requires an upfront $10,000 and then has a 0.6 probability of an operating payoff of $100,000 and a 0.4 probability of -$20,000. Option B requires $5,000 and has a 0.5 probability of an operating payoff of $60,000 and a 0.5 probability of $20,000. Payoffs exclude the upfront costs. (a) Calculate A's net expected value. (b) Calculate B's net expected value. (c) Identify the higher.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. A's expected operating payoff = 0.6($100000) + 0.4(-$20000) = $52000; deduct $10000 for $42000 net expected value.
    2. B gives 0.5($60000) + 0.5($20000) - $5000 = $35000. A exceeds B by $7000, but the weighted average is not a guaranteed one-off outcome.

    Common mistake: Subtract each upfront cost once, not once again after net outcomes.

    Marking points

    • Calculates the expected value of Option A's outcomes: (0.6 × 100,000) + (0.4 × −20,000) = 60,000 − 8,000 = $52,000.
    • Subtracts the cost of Option A: 52,000 − 10,000 = $42,000.
    • Calculates the expected value of Option B's outcomes: (0.5 × 60,000) + (0.5 × 20,000) = 30,000 + 10,000 = $40,000.
    • Subtracts the cost of Option B: 40,000 − 5,000 = $35,000.
    • States that Option A has the higher net expected value ($42,000 versus $35,000).

    Examiner tip: Subtract the upfront cost once: either from the weighted average payoff or from every outcome before probability-weighting. Both methods agree because the probabilities sum to one.

  2. 2.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Option A requires an upfront $10,000 and then has a 0.6 probability of an operating payoff of $100,000 and a 0.4 probability of -$20,000. Option B requires $5,000 and has a 0.5 probability of an operating payoff of $60,000 and a 0.5 probability of $20,000. Payoffs exclude the upfront costs. (a) Calculate A's net expected value. (b) Calculate B's net expected value. (c) Identify the higher.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates the expected value of Option A's outcomes: (0.6 × 100,000) + (0.4 × −20,000) = 60,000 − 8,000 = $52,000.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates the expected value of Option A's outcomes: (0.6 × 100,000) + (0.4 × −20,000) = 60,000 − 8,000 = $52,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Subtracts the cost of Option A: 52,000 − 10,000 = $42,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the expected value of Option B's outcomes: (0.5 × 60,000) + (0.5 × 20,000) = 30,000 + 10,000 = $40,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Subtracts the cost of Option B: 40,000 − 5,000 = $35,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that Option A has the higher net expected value ($42,000 versus $35,000).

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  3. 3.

    Option A has net outcomes of $90,000 (probability 0.6) and -$30,000 (0.4), giving net expected value $42,000. Option B has net outcomes of $55,000 and $15,000 (each probability 0.5), giving $35,000. Explain one limitation of using expected value alone to choose between them.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A's $42000 expectation conceals a 40% chance of losing $30000; B's worst stated outcome is a positive $15000.
    2. A cash-constrained manager might prefer B despite its lower $35000 average because a single large loss could threaten liquidity. Expected value does not encode survival needs or risk aversion.

    Common mistake: The average payoff is not an outcome guaranteed to occur.

    Marking points

    • Explains that expected value is a long-run average outcome and does not capture a decision-maker's attitude toward risk, such as risk-aversion.
    • Explains that a risk-averse or cash-constrained manager may prefer B, whose net payoff is positive in both stated outcomes, to A with a 40% chance of a $30,000 total net loss.

    Examiner tip: Expected value is a useful starting point for decision-making but should never be the only factor considered — the spread/range of possible outcomes and the decision-maker's risk tolerance both matter in practice.

  4. 4.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Option A has net outcomes of $90,000 (probability 0.6) and -$30,000 (0.4), giving net expected value $42,000. Option B has net outcomes of $55,000 and $15,000 (each probability 0.5), giving $35,000. Explain one limitation of using expected value alone to choose between them.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that expected value is a long-run average outcome and does not capture a decision-maker's attitude toward risk, such as risk-aversion.” Evaluate the response against the complete 2-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that expected value is a long-run average outcome and does not capture a decision-maker's attitude toward risk, such as risk-aversion.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that a risk-averse or cash-constrained manager may prefer B, whose net payoff is positive in both stated outcomes, to A with a 40% chance of a $30,000 total net loss.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  5. 5.

    Define 'critical path' in the context of critical path analysis (network planning), and explain why identifying it is important for project managers.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. The critical path is the longest dependent activity sequence, setting earliest project completion rather than the shortest route through the diagram.
    2. Its zero-float activities need close monitoring: delaying one delays completion unless another duration is reduced. Non-critical work offers limited scheduling flexibility, not unlimited delay.

    Common mistake: Critical means schedule-constraining, not merely expensive.

    Marking points

    • Defines the critical path as the longest sequence of dependent activities through a project network, determining the minimum possible time needed to complete the whole project.
    • Explains that any delay to an activity on the critical path directly delays the entire project's completion date, since there is no spare time (float) built into these activities.
    • Explains that project managers should therefore prioritize monitoring and resourcing critical path activities most closely, since they have the greatest impact on whether the project finishes on time.

    Examiner tip: Activities not on the critical path have 'float' (spare time) and can be delayed slightly without affecting the overall project finish date — this is the key distinction examiners expect between critical and non-critical activities.

  6. 6.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Define 'critical path' in the context of critical path analysis (network planning), and explain why identifying it is important for project managers.” Their response addresses only this point: “Defines the critical path as the longest sequence of dependent activities through a project network, determining the minimum possible time needed to complete the whole project.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Defines the critical path as the longest sequence of dependent activities through a project network, determining the minimum possible time needed to complete the whole project.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that any delay to an activity on the critical path directly delays the entire project's completion date, since there is no spare time (float) built into these activities.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that project managers should therefore prioritize monitoring and resourcing critical path activities most closely, since they have the greatest impact on whether the project finishes on time.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  7. 7.

    A project has the following activities: Activity A (2 days) must be completed first. Activity B (3 days) and Activity C (4 days) can both start once A is finished. Activity D (2 days) can only start once both B and C are finished. (a) Calculate the total duration of path A-B-D. (b) Calculate the total duration of path A-C-D. (c) Identify the critical path and state the minimum project duration. (d) Calculate the float (spare time) available on activity B.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. A-B-D takes 2 + 3 + 2 = 7 days; A-C-D takes 2 + 4 + 2 = 8, making A-C-D critical.
    2. B starts after day 2 and normally finishes day 5; D waits for C until day 6. B can slip one day without moving completion, so its float is one day.

    Common mistake: Do not add parallel B and C durations sequentially.

    Marking points

    • Calculates the duration of path A-B-D as 2 + 3 + 2 = 7 days.
    • Calculates the duration of path A-C-D as 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 days.
    • Identifies A-C-D as the critical path, since it is the longer of the two paths, and states the minimum project duration as 8 days.
    • Calculates the float on activity B as the difference between the critical path duration and the duration of the path containing B: 8 − 7 = 1 day.

    Examiner tip: Here B alone lies on the shorter branch, so its total float is 8 - 7 = 1 day. In general use latest start minus earliest start (or latest finish minus earliest finish); an activity shared with a critical path can have zero float even if it also lies on a shorter path.

  8. 8.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A project has the following activities: Activity A (2 days) must be completed first. Activity B (3 days) and Activity C (4 days) can both start once A is finished. Activity D (2 days) can only start once both B and C are finished. (a) Calculate the total duration of path A-B-D. (b) Calculate the total duration of path A-C-D. (c) Identify the critical path and state the minimum project duration. (d) Calculate the float (spare time) available on activity B.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates the duration of path A-B-D as 2 + 3 + 2 = 7 days.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates the duration of path A-B-D as 2 + 3 + 2 = 7 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the duration of path A-C-D as 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Identifies A-C-D as the critical path, since it is the longer of the two paths, and states the minimum project duration as 8 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the float on activity B as the difference between the critical path duration and the duration of the path containing B: 8 − 7 = 1 day.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  9. 9.

    Explain two benefits to a project manager of using critical path analysis before starting a complex project.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A dependency network reveals the earliest feasible completion under estimated durations, preventing deadlines based only on adding every activity.
    2. Its float identifies where a resource can be shifted toward critical work without delaying completion. Staffing availability still needs checking: the basic network does not guarantee resources for parallel tasks.

    Common mistake: A time-feasible plan may still be resource-infeasible.

    Marking points

    • Explains that critical path analysis identifies the minimum possible time to complete the project, allowing for realistic scheduling and deadline-setting before work begins.
    • Explains that it identifies which activities have float (spare time) and which do not, helping managers allocate resources (staff, equipment, attention) more efficiently by prioritizing critical activities.

    Examiner tip: Critical path analysis is fundamentally a planning and resource-allocation tool — its value comes from identifying constraints and flexibility before problems occur, not from solving problems after they arise.

  10. 10.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain two benefits to a project manager of using critical path analysis before starting a complex project.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that critical path analysis identifies the minimum possible time to complete the project, allowing for realistic scheduling and deadline-setting before work begins.” Evaluate the response against the complete 2-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that critical path analysis identifies the minimum possible time to complete the project, allowing for realistic scheduling and deadline-setting before work begins.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that it identifies which activities have float (spare time) and which do not, helping managers allocate resources (staff, equipment, attention) more efficiently by prioritizing critical activities.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  11. 11.

    State one limitation of critical path analysis as a planning tool.

    [1 mark] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A duration estimate that is too optimistic can put the wrong activities on the apparent critical path.
    2. For example, an assumed two-day delivery taking five can overturn the completion date; revise estimates and contingencies rather than treat the network's exact arithmetic as forecast certainty.

    Common mistake: Precise arithmetic does not make uncertain durations accurate.

    Marking points

    • States a valid limitation, such as the technique relying on activity duration estimates that may be inaccurate, or that it does not account for resource constraints (e.g., the same staff being needed for two simultaneous activities).

    Examiner tip: Like any quantitative planning model, critical path analysis is only as reliable as the time estimates fed into it — inaccurate estimates for individual activities will produce an inaccurate critical path and project duration.

  12. 12.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “State one limitation of critical path analysis as a planning tool.” Their response addresses only this point: “States a valid limitation, such as the technique relying on activity duration estimates that may be inaccurate, or that it does not account for resource constraints (e.g., the same staff being needed for two simultaneous activities).” Evaluate the response against the complete 1-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [1 mark] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States a valid limitation, such as the technique relying on activity duration estimates that may be inaccurate, or that it does not account for resource constraints (e.g., the same staff being needed for two simultaneous activities).

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  13. 13.

    A project has activities: A (3 days) first; B (4 days) and C (2 days) both follow A; D (5 days) follows both B and C; E (2 days) follows D. (a) Calculate the length of path A-B-D-E and path A-C-D-E. (b) State the critical path and minimum duration. (c) Calculate the float on activity C.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. A-B-D-E = 3 + 4 + 5 + 2 = 14 days; A-C-D-E = 3 + 2 + 5 + 2 = 12.
    2. The critical path is A-B-D-E. C can finish at day 7 instead of day 5 before D's start changes, so C has two days' float; shared A, D and E do not inherit that float.

    Common mistake: A shorter path does not give every activity on it spare time.

    Marking points

    • Calculates path A-B-D-E as 3 + 4 + 5 + 2 = 14 days.
    • Calculates path A-C-D-E as 3 + 2 + 5 + 2 = 12 days.
    • States the critical path is A-B-D-E with a minimum duration of 14 days.
    • Calculates the float on C as 14 − 12 = 2 days.

    Examiner tip: C has two days of float in this simple network. Generally calculate activity float from latest and earliest times; subtracting a shorter path's length is not a universal activity-level rule.

  14. 14.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A project has activities: A (3 days) first; B (4 days) and C (2 days) both follow A; D (5 days) follows both B and C; E (2 days) follows D. (a) Calculate the length of path A-B-D-E and path A-C-D-E. (b) State the critical path and minimum duration. (c) Calculate the float on activity C.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates path A-B-D-E as 3 + 4 + 5 + 2 = 14 days.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates path A-B-D-E as 3 + 4 + 5 + 2 = 14 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates path A-C-D-E as 3 + 2 + 5 + 2 = 12 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States the critical path is A-B-D-E with a minimum duration of 14 days.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the float on C as 14 − 12 = 2 days.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  15. 15.

    Explain how a project manager could shorten the duration of a project shown by a network diagram, and state one cost of doing so.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Add effective labour or equipment to a critical activity to shorten its duration, provided the task can actually be accelerated.
    2. Overtime or extra equipment costs money, and another path may then become critical. Recalculate before paying for further reductions; accelerating a non-critical task alone does not move the deadline.

    Common mistake: More resources cannot always compress technically fixed waiting time.

    Marking points

    • Explains that only shortening activities on the critical path reduces total duration, e.g. by adding labour or equipment to them.
    • Notes that once a path is shortened, another path may become critical, limiting further savings.
    • States a cost, such as extra labour or equipment costs, or overtime payments.

    Examiner tip: Spending money on non-critical activities does not shorten the project.

  16. 16.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain how a project manager could shorten the duration of a project shown by a network diagram, and state one cost of doing so.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that only shortening activities on the critical path reduces total duration, e.g. by adding labour or equipment to them.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that only shortening activities on the critical path reduces total duration, e.g. by adding labour or equipment to them.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Notes that once a path is shortened, another path may become critical, limiting further savings.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States a cost, such as extra labour or equipment costs, or overtime payments.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  17. 17.

    A firm sells a product for $25 with variable cost of $15 per unit; fixed costs are $40,000. (a) Calculate the break-even quantity. (b) Calculate the sales needed to earn a target profit of $20,000. (c) Calculate the margin of safety, as a percentage of actual sales, if 7,000 units are sold.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Contribution = $25 - $15 = $10. Break-even = $40000/$10 = 4000 units; target-profit output = ($40000 + $20000)/$10 = 6000.
    2. At 7000 sales, safety margin = 3000 units, or 3000/7000 x 100 = 42.9% of actual sales. Target sales revenue is 6000 x $25 = $150000.

    Common mistake: Use actual sales, not break-even output, for the requested percentage.

    Marking points

    • Calculates contribution per unit as 25 − 15 = $10.
    • Calculates break-even as 40,000 / 10 = 4,000 units.
    • Calculates target-profit output as (40,000 + 20,000) / 10 = 6,000 units.
    • Calculates margin of safety as (7,000 − 4,000) / 7,000 × 100 ≈ 42.9%.

    Examiner tip: For a profit target, add it to fixed costs before dividing by contribution per unit.

  18. 18.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A firm sells a product for $25 with variable cost of $15 per unit; fixed costs are $40,000. (a) Calculate the break-even quantity. (b) Calculate the sales needed to earn a target profit of $20,000. (c) Calculate the margin of safety, as a percentage of actual sales, if 7,000 units are sold.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates contribution per unit as 25 − 15 = $10.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates contribution per unit as 25 − 15 = $10.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates break-even as 40,000 / 10 = 4,000 units.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates target-profit output as (40,000 + 20,000) / 10 = 6,000 units.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates margin of safety as (7,000 − 4,000) / 7,000 × 100 ≈ 42.9%.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  19. 19.

    A firm produced 12,000 units with 40 workers at a total cost of $96,000. Calculate (a) labour productivity and (b) unit cost, and (c) explain one way the firm could lower unit cost without cutting wages.

    [3 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Labour productivity = 12000/40 = 300 units per worker; unit cost = $96000/12000 = $8.
    2. Training that reduces scrap could raise saleable output from the same paid hours, spreading costs more effectively without wage cuts. Include training and any equipment cost when assessing the eventual saving.

    Common mistake: Producing more defective units does not improve saleable productivity.

    Marking points

    • Calculates labour productivity as 12,000 / 40 = 300 units per worker.
    • Calculates unit cost as 96,000 / 12,000 = $8.
    • Explains a method such as raising productivity through training or better equipment so more units are produced from the same cost base.

    Examiner tip: Unit cost falls when output per worker rises while total cost stays roughly constant.

  20. 20.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A firm produced 12,000 units with 40 workers at a total cost of $96,000. Calculate (a) labour productivity and (b) unit cost, and (c) explain one way the firm could lower unit cost without cutting wages.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates labour productivity as 12,000 / 40 = 300 units per worker.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates labour productivity as 12,000 / 40 = 300 units per worker.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates unit cost as 96,000 / 12,000 = $8.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains a method such as raising productivity through training or better equipment so more units are produced from the same cost base.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  21. 21.

    Evaluate the use of just-in-time (JIT) production compared with just-in-case stock holding for a supermarket.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. JIT can reduce supermarket refrigeration space, cash tied up and spoilage, especially for perishables, but late deliveries create empty shelves and lost baskets.
    2. I would combine frequent deliveries of predictable perishables with buffers of durable high-demand staples where disruption is costly. Pure just-in-case stock protects availability but can waste food; supplier reliability and shelf life determine the balance.

    Common mistake: One stock policy need not suit every supermarket product.

    Marking points

    • Explains the JIT benefit: lower storage costs, less waste of perishable goods and less cash tied up in stock.
    • Explains the JIT risk: stock-outs and lost sales if deliveries are late or demand spikes.
    • Explains that just-in-case holding protects availability but raises storage and wastage costs.
    • Reaches a justified judgement, e.g. a hybrid: JIT for perishables with reliable suppliers, buffer stock for high-demand staples.

    Examiner tip: Evaluation needs a conclusion that depends on context: product type, supplier reliability and cost of a stock-out.

  22. 22.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Evaluate the use of just-in-time (JIT) production compared with just-in-case stock holding for a supermarket.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains the JIT benefit: lower storage costs, less waste of perishable goods and less cash tied up in stock.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains the JIT benefit: lower storage costs, less waste of perishable goods and less cash tied up in stock.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains the JIT risk: stock-outs and lost sales if deliveries are late or demand spikes.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that just-in-case holding protects availability but raises storage and wastage costs.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Reaches a justified judgement, e.g. a hybrid: JIT for perishables with reliable suppliers, buffer stock for high-demand staples.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  23. 23.

    Explain how a business adopting total quality management (TQM) may reduce its costs in the long run despite higher short-run costs.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. TQM initially needs training, process redesign and monitoring, consuming cash and staff time.
    2. More reliable processes can later reduce scrap, rework and complaint-handling hours. Savings justify the effort only if failure costs avoided exceed prevention costs; a reputation gain alone does not demonstrate lower production cost.

    Common mistake: Higher sales are not themselves evidence of a cost reduction.

    Marking points

    • Explains that TQM requires short-run spending on training, process redesign and monitoring.
    • Explains that fewer defects reduce scrap, rework, returns and warranty claims over time.
    • Develops a further cost mechanism, for example more reliable processes reducing wasted materials, downtime or the staff time spent handling complaints. A sales benefit alone does not explain a cost reduction.

    Examiner tip: The cost of quality: prevention costs now are usually cheaper than failure costs later.

  24. 24.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain how a business adopting total quality management (TQM) may reduce its costs in the long run despite higher short-run costs.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that TQM requires short-run spending on training, process redesign and monitoring.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that TQM requires short-run spending on training, process redesign and monitoring.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that fewer defects reduce scrap, rework, returns and warranty claims over time.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Develops a further cost mechanism, for example more reliable processes reducing wasted materials, downtime or the staff time spent handling complaints. A sales benefit alone does not explain a cost reduction.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  25. 25.

    Explain two potential benefits and one drawback to a manufacturer of introducing greater automation.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Automation can increase output per paid hour and improve repeatable precision, reducing labour input and defect-related waste.
    2. Large capital outlays and reprogramming costs can make it unattractive for small customised runs. Compare throughput and consistency gains with volume, flexibility and finance requirements, not wages alone.

    Common mistake: Machines do not necessarily run without maintenance or skilled staff.

    Marking points

    • Explains a benefit such as higher productivity and consistency of output with fewer errors.
    • Explains a second benefit such as lower long-run unit labour costs and the ability to run continuously.
    • Explains a drawback such as high capital cost, job losses and lower flexibility for small or customised orders.

    Examiner tip: Automation trades flexibility and up-front capital for productivity and consistency, so it suits high-volume standardized output.

  26. 26.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain two potential benefits and one drawback to a manufacturer of introducing greater automation.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains a benefit such as higher productivity and consistency of output with fewer errors.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains a benefit such as higher productivity and consistency of output with fewer errors.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains a second benefit such as lower long-run unit labour costs and the ability to run continuously.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains a drawback such as high capital cost, job losses and lower flexibility for small or customised orders.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  27. 27.

    Explain two limitations of break-even analysis as a decision-making tool.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A constant-price, linear-cost break-even calculation can mislead when discounts reduce selling price or bulk purchases change variable unit cost.
    2. It also cannot establish whether customers will buy the calculated volume; unsold production generates cost without forecast sales revenue. Test demand and capacity steps before using the threshold as a decision.

    Common mistake: Break-even output is not a sales forecast.

    Marking points

    • Explains that it assumes a constant selling price and linear costs, whereas prices may fall with volume and variable costs may change with bulk buying.
    • Explains that it assumes everything produced is sold and ignores demand uncertainty and changes in fixed costs at higher output.

    Examiner tip: Break-even is a simplified model; its answers are only as reliable as its assumptions.

  28. 28.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain two limitations of break-even analysis as a decision-making tool.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that it assumes a constant selling price and linear costs, whereas prices may fall with volume and variable costs may change with bulk buying.” Evaluate the response against the complete 2-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [2 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that it assumes a constant selling price and linear costs, whereas prices may fall with volume and variable costs may change with bulk buying.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that it assumes everything produced is sold and ignores demand uncertainty and changes in fixed costs at higher output.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  29. 29.

    An investment costs $20,000 initially. Its subsequent cash payoff, excluding that cost, is $80,000 with probability 0.7 or $10,000 with probability 0.3. Calculate net expected value and state the choice using the net-expected-value criterion alone, compared with doing nothing (net value $0).

    [3 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Expected payoff = 0.7($80000) + 0.3($10000) = $59000. Deduct initial $20000 for net expected value $39000.
    2. Proceed under that criterion alone because $39000 exceeds doing nothing's zero. The low outcome still loses $10000 after cost, so the criterion does not eliminate downside risk.

    Common mistake: The $10000 low payoff is not net profit.

    Marking points

    • Calculates expected return as (0.7 × 80,000) + (0.3 × 10,000) = 56,000 + 3,000 = $59,000.
    • Subtracts the cost: 59,000 − 20,000 = $39,000.
    • States that the firm should proceed, as $39,000 exceeds the $0 alternative, noting the risk of the lower outcome.

    Examiner tip: Weight each outcome by its probability, add them, then subtract the cost of the decision.

  30. 30.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “An investment costs $20,000 initially. Its subsequent cash payoff, excluding that cost, is $80,000 with probability 0.7 or $10,000 with probability 0.3. Calculate net expected value and state the choice using the net-expected-value criterion alone, compared with doing nothing (net value $0).” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates expected return as (0.7 × 80,000) + (0.3 × 10,000) = 56,000 + 3,000 = $59,000.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates expected return as (0.7 × 80,000) + (0.3 × 10,000) = 56,000 + 3,000 = $59,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Subtracts the cost: 59,000 − 20,000 = $39,000.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that the firm should proceed, as $39,000 exceeds the $0 alternative, noting the risk of the lower outcome.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.