Business Management SL
Business Research Design and Evidence
- 1.
Research preparation only. A hypothetical local repair shop is considering collection lockers because customers cannot visit during opening hours. Replace 'Is technology good for business?' with a focused research question about this one organization. Explain how change could guide analysis and identify two relevant evidence needs. Do not claim to have investigated a real organization.
[4 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- Name the organization and the decision, rather than researching technology in general. Set a time horizon so costs and outcomes can be compared.
- Use change to examine the transition in operations and customer access. A later authentic project needs independently selected evidence about a real organization; this fictional proposal supplies neither research findings nor supporting documents.
Common mistake: Adding the word change to a title is not the same as using it to analyse a business decision.
Marking points
- Formulates a bounded question such as whether the repair shop should introduce collection lockers in the next trading year.
- Connects change to the shop's service process, customer access or employee duties.
- Identifies evidence of customer demand for out-of-hours collection.
- Identifies cost, staffing, security or service-time evidence needed to compare lockers with the current process.
Examiner tip: Adding the word change to a title is not the same as using it to analyse a business decision.
- 2.
Research preparation only. For a hypothetical refill shop's packaging decision, four candidate evidence items are described: its supplier's price quotation, its manager's promotional blog, an independent local consumer survey with sampling details, and a council waste report. Recommend three for a starting evidence plan, explain why the selection is balanced, and identify one limitation to investigate. These descriptions are not authentic supporting documents.
[4 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- Match evidence to separate parts of the decision: cost, customer response and environmental context. The manager's blog may reveal objectives but cannot independently substantiate benefits.
- Check dates, sampling and applicability before choosing actual documents. Balance is about differing perspectives and relevance, not simply choosing three items with different titles.
Common mistake: Three promotional documents from the same business would not automatically provide independent corroboration.
Marking points
- Selects the supplier quotation for option-specific packaging costs.
- Selects the consumer survey for demand evidence from outside management.
- Selects the council report for independent waste context; explains that this adds perspective beyond the promotional blog.
- Identifies a concrete limitation, such as an unrepresentative survey sample, irrelevant local waste categories, outdated publication or quotation conditions.
Examiner tip: Three promotional documents from the same business would not automatically provide independent corroboration.
- 3.
Research preparation only. A hypothetical bike shop sells 400 services per year at $50 each, with variable cost $20 each. A booking platform would add $1800 annual fixed cost and is forecast to add 80 services; price and variable cost per service stay unchanged and capacity is sufficient. Calculate its forecast incremental annual profit, give one forecast limitation and make a conditional recommendation. Ignore tax and capital costs.
[4 marks]Worked explanation
- Use incremental contribution, not the whole $50 selling price: extra services also incur the $20 variable cost.
- Eighty extra services contribute $2400; after the annual fee the increase is $600. $1800/$30 = 60 extra services is the threshold, so verify incremental demand before treating the forecast as a research conclusion.
Common mistake: Do not count the platform's total bookings as additional sales when some may replace existing bookings.
Marking points
- Contribution per additional service = $50 - $20 = $30.
- Incremental annual profit = 80 x $30 - $1800 = $600.
- Identifies a specific uncertainty such as whether 80 extra bookings are genuinely additional rather than existing customers switching channel.
- Conditionally supports adoption if demand evidence sustains the forecast; notes that 60 extra services are needed just to cover the annual platform cost.
Examiner tip: Do not count the platform's total bookings as additional sales when some may replace existing bookings.
- 4.
Research preparation only for a fictional uniform maker considering a larger school order next term. For a proposed order, September opening cash would be $2000. The only September inflow would be a $1000 customer deposit, while materials and wages totalling $4500 must be paid in September. The customer would pay the remaining $5000 in October. All $4500 is the order's total cost, with no other costs, tax or cash flows. Calculate September closing cash and the forecast order profit, then explain why the profit does not establish that the change is affordable. Specify one piece of cash-timing evidence to verify. Do not present the proposal as real research or completed coursework.
[4 marks]Syllabus placement evidence: IB Business management guide, first assessment 2024, updated July 2024; 3.7 Cash flow, printed pp.29-30; Internal assessment, pp.53-55 and criteria C-E, pp.57-58.. Applies shared SL/HL cash-flow forecasting and the profit/cash distinction to evidence-based appraisal of one organization's proposed change. Core for the existing first-assessment-2024 SL curriculum; preparation only, with fictional planning inputs, not supporting documents or completed independently researched assessed work.
Worked explanation
- Construct a September cash schedule rather than placing every order receipt in the same month: only $1000 arrives before the $4500 payment. The calculated negative closing balance shows a financing requirement, not permission to spend nonexistent cash.
- Separately compare total sales of $6000 with total costs of $4500. The $1500 surplus over the order does not bridge the earlier $1500 cash gap; under change, check payment terms and financing feasibility before treating the expansion as affordable.
Common mistake: Do not include October receipts in September cash or treat a profitable forecast as proof that payments can be made on time.
Marking points
- Calculates September closing cash as $2000 + $1000 - $4500 = -$1500, an unfunded shortfall before any finance is arranged.
- Calculates forecast order profit as ($1000 + $5000) - $4500 = $1500 over the whole order.
- Explains that October receipts cannot meet September payments without bridging finance or renegotiated timing, so a profitable order can still create a liquidity problem.
- Requests verification of the customer's contractual payment date/deposit or the supplier/payroll due dates before recommending the proposed change.
Examiner tip: Do not include October receipts in September cash or treat a profitable forecast as proof that payments can be made on time.
- 5.
Research preparation only. A fictional furniture repairer asks whether to introduce a reclaimed-wood product line using sustainability as its conceptual lens. A planning sheet supplies three unverified claims: existing employees already have joinery skills; an external supplier is offering a reliable stream of reclaimed wood; and local energy prices may rise. A draft SWOT lists all three as strengths and concludes that environmental benefits and profit are guaranteed. Correct the classification of each claim with a reason, and propose one measurable evidence test for the environmental claim. Treat the claims as planning assumptions, not authentic research findings; do not write the IA.
[4 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: IB Business management guide, first assessment 2024, updated July 2024; The business management toolkit, printed p.14: SWOT analysis; Internal assessment, pp.53-55 and criteria A, C-D, pp.56-58.. Uses a shared toolkit method and integrates sustainability through an evidence test for one fictional organization's issue. Core SL preparation in the current curriculum; a SWOT is neither exhaustive mapping nor independently obtained supporting evidence, and no completed project or measured environmental saving is claimed.
Worked explanation
- For each claim, ask whether it describes a capability already inside the repairer or a condition outside it, then whether it helps or threatens the proposal. A supplier's offer is an external opening, not yet an owned resource.
- Use the corrected SWOT to organise questions, not certify results. Under sustainability, define a comparable product baseline and measure resource inputs or waste avoided alongside extra processing and transport; neither the SWOT labels nor the reclaimed-wood label establishes net benefit or profit.
Common mistake: Do not call every favourable external condition an internal strength, or treat a SWOT list as measured proof of sustainability and profitability.
Marking points
- Classifies existing employee skills as an internal strength because they are a current organizational capability.
- Classifies the external supply offer as an opportunity rather than an existing internal strength, while treating reliability as needing verification.
- Classifies a possible external energy-price increase as a threat because it may raise costs, not a strength supporting guaranteed profit.
- Proposes a relevant comparative test, such as measuring reclaimed versus new wood use and processing/transport energy per comparable item, explaining that net environmental benefit depends on the comparison.
Examiner tip: Do not call every favourable external condition an internal strength, or treat a SWOT list as measured proof of sustainability and profitability.
- 6.
Research preparation only. A fictional repair shop records five completed repair times of 2, 3, 3, 4 and 18 days. These are all five repairs completed during the observation period, and no recording error is established. Calculate the mean and median. A manager proposes advertising 'all repairs take three days' and deleting the 18-day repair from the evidence. Evaluate both proposals and identify one additional piece of evidence needed before promising a future turnaround time. Use ethics as the conceptual lens; the figures are invented, not authentic research or a completed IA.
[5 marks]Syllabus placement evidence: IB Business management guide, first assessment 2024, public edition updated May 2022: The business management toolkit, printed p.14, descriptive statistics; internal assessment, business research project.. Mean and median are listed shared SL/HL toolkit methods. Applies them to evidence appraisal under ethics in the existing preparation topic, not an additional IA requirement. The later July 2024 examiner-linked edition was inaccessible in this pass, so a teacher must confirm session-specific requirements. No supporting documents or completed research are supplied.
Worked explanation
- The total is 30 repair-days across five repairs, so the mean is 6 days. The ordered middle value is 3 days. The long repair raises the mean but does not change which value is in the middle.
- The two summaries describe these completed repairs differently; neither proves all repairs finish within three days. Under ethics, keep the adverse record and investigate its cause rather than removing it to improve advertising. Completed repairs also omit any unfinished jobs, which should be checked before forecasting turnaround.
Common mistake: A median is not a completion guarantee, and an extreme observation is not automatically an error.
Marking points
- Calculates the mean as (2 + 3 + 3 + 4 + 18)/5 = 6 days.
- Calculates the median as the third ordered observation, 3 days.
- Rejects the universal three-day claim: two observed repairs exceeded three days, and neither a mean nor a median is a maximum or guarantee.
- Retains the 18-day observation unless a documented error or defensible inclusion rule justifies correction or exclusion; an inconvenient genuine delay is relevant to customers.
- Requests relevant forward-looking evidence, such as the reason for the long delay, repair-type mix or parts availability, before promising future service times.
Examiner tip: A median is not a completion guarantee, and an extreme observation is not automatically an error.