Economics HL
Economic Models and Opportunity Cost
- 1.
A hypothetical economy's efficient annual combinations of solar panels and bicycles are A (0,120), B (10,110), C (20,90), D (30,60). Calculate the bicycle opportunity cost per additional panel for each successive interval and explain the pattern.
[4 marks]Worked explanation
- Take the fall in bicycles divided by the rise in panels in each interval: 10/10, 20/10, 30/10.
- The results 1, 2 and 3 bicycles per panel increase. This is consistent with specialised resources rather than a constant-cost straight-line PPC.
Common mistake: Use bicycles forgone per panel, not the inverse ratio or the total bicycle output at each point.
Marking points
- A to B sacrifices 10 bicycles for 10 panels: 1 bicycle per panel.
- B to C sacrifices 20 bicycles for 10 panels: 2 bicycles per panel.
- C to D sacrifices 30 bicycles for 10 panels: 3 bicycles per panel.
- Explains increasing opportunity cost through resources being progressively less suited to panel production.
Examiner tip: Use bicycles forgone per panel, not the inverse ratio or the total bicycle output at each point.
- 2.
In a hypothetical circular-flow model, households save $20 million, taxes are $15 million and imports $10 million per year. Investment is $25 million, government spending $12 million and exports $8 million per year. Calculate total leakages and injections. Explain whether these totals alone establish full employment.
[4 marks]Worked explanation
- Keep household saving, taxes and imports on the leakage side; investment, government spending and exports are injections.
- Both sides equal $45 million annually. Balance describes spending consistency, not whether the economy uses every available resource.
Common mistake: Do not treat equal injections and leakages as proof that unemployment is zero.
Marking points
- Leakages are 20 + 15 + 10 = $45 million per year.
- Injections are 25 + 12 + 8 = $45 million per year.
- Equal totals mean no net spending addition or withdrawal at the stated income in this model.
- A spending equilibrium can occur below full employment, so employment or potential-output evidence is still needed.
Examiner tip: Do not treat equal injections and leakages as proof that unemployment is zero.
- 3.
A hypothetical town cuts a product's sales tax; its sales then fall while a major employer closes. A student says this proves that lower prices can never raise quantity demanded. Explain two problems with this inference and propose one improvement to the investigation.
[3 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- Separate the price channel from changes in demand conditions. Job losses could dominate any movement along the demand curve.
- Establish pass-through using actual transaction prices; then compare a suitably similar market or adjust for income changes. One confounded observation does not establish a universal law.
Common mistake: Sales following a tax change do not isolate the effect of price when income and possibly pass-through also change.
Marking points
- The employer closure can lower incomes and shift demand, violating ceteris paribus.
- A tax cut may not be fully passed into the consumer price, so the proposed price change needs verification.
- Proposes checking actual prices and using a comparable unaffected town or controlling for income and other demand changes.
Examiner tip: Sales following a tax change do not isolate the effect of price when income and possibly pass-through also change.
- 4.
For a fictional model, assume ordinary outdoor air is abundant relative to breathing needs and that one extra breath does not displace anyone else's use or require production resources. A hospital, however, must use scarce electricity, specialist equipment and staff time to provide purified oxygen in cylinders. The cylinders are supplied to patients at a zero price. Distinguish the economic classification of the outdoor air and the supplied cylinders, explaining why processing and location matter and why the patient price is not decisive.
[4 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, published February 2020, updated October 2022, edition linked by 2026 examiner instructions; Unit 1, 1.1, printed pp.22-23: scarcity, opportunity cost and free goods.. Tests the free-good boundary through scarce processing inputs and location, not merely another numerical PPC trade-off. This is shared introductory SL/HL content placed core in the existing HL track; fictional practice with conditional assumptions, not an assertion that all air is always a free good.
Worked explanation
- Apply the opportunity-cost test to the exact item in the exact setting. Under the outdoor-air assumptions, extra use sacrifices no alternative; hospital-ready oxygen requires resources that could provide other services.
- Do not transfer a classification from a raw natural resource to its processed, located form. Funding the cylinders collectively leaves the production trade-off intact even when the user pays nothing.
Common mistake: Neither being found in nature nor having a zero selling price is sufficient to make a supplied product a free good.
Marking points
- Classifies outdoor air as a free good under the explicitly stated abundance and no-displacement assumptions.
- Classifies supplied purified oxygen cylinders as economic goods because provision uses scarce resources with alternative uses.
- Explains that processing and delivery at the required location change resource requirements, so the two products need not share a classification despite their common atmospheric origin.
- Explains that a zero patient price changes who pays, not the opportunity cost of electricity, equipment and staff time.
Examiner tip: Neither being found in nature nor having a zero selling price is sufficient to make a supplied product a free good.
- 5.
A fictional community must allocate 100 identical emergency food parcels between two groups of equal population. Group A has no alternative food supply; Group B has enough alternative food to meet half of its needs. Plan E gives each group 50 parcels. Plan N gives A 70 and B 30. Explain which plan gives equal parcel allocations, construct a reasoned need-based equity argument for N, identify the value judgement in that argument, and state one further fact needed before deciding whether N adequately meets needs. Do not assume parcels measure every aspect of wellbeing.
[4 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, published February 2020, updated October 2022, edition linked by 2026 examiner instructions; Unit 1, 1.2 How do economists approach the world?, printed p.23: normative economics, value judgements, equity and equality.. Applies the specifically listed equity/equality distinction and the role of values, without requiring HL-only inequality indices. Core shared introductory content in this HL cohort; a bounded fictional reasoning task, not a complete evaluation of distributive justice or an IA submission.
Worked explanation
- Hold the meaning of equality fixed: compare parcels per person, not total access to food. E is equal by that metric, but unequal alternative supplies mean parcel equality need not equalise need satisfaction.
- State the fairness principle before defending N. The supplied need difference supports giving A more under that principle, but without the scale of food requirements it cannot justify exactly 70/30 as sufficient or uniquely fair.
Common mistake: A need-based case for unequal shares does not prove that a particular split is sufficient, objectively fairest or equal in every outcome.
Marking points
- Identifies E as equal parcel allocations, and, because group populations are equal, equal parcels per person.
- Explains that N could be judged more equitable under a need-based principle because A has less access to alternative food.
- Identifies prioritising unmet need rather than identical shares as a normative fairness judgement, not a fact proved by the allocation numbers.
- Requests group food requirements relative to parcel contents, or equivalent evidence of the shortfall, to assess whether the 70/30 split actually meets needs.
Examiner tip: A need-based case for unequal shares does not prove that a particular split is sufficient, objectively fairest or equal in every outcome.