IB · ECON HL

Economics HL

Government intervention and welfare analysis (HL) — Unit 2 HL

Name: ____________________Date: November 19, 2026
  1. 1.

    In a market, demand is Qd = 200 − 4P and supply is Qs = 6P − 40. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium price and quantity. (b) The government imposes a price ceiling of $15. Calculate the resulting quantity demanded, quantity supplied, and the size of the shortage.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Set 200 - 4P = 6P - 40: 240 = 10P, so P = $24 and Q = 104 units. The $15 ceiling is below equilibrium and therefore binding.
    2. At $15, Qd = 200 - 60 = 140 while Qs = 90 - 40 = 50. Shortage = 140 - 50 = 90 units; only 50 units are offered at the legal price, not 140.

    Common mistake: Treating the 90-unit shortage as the quantity actually traded rather than unmet demand.

    Marking points

    • Sets Qd = Qs: 200 − 4P = 6P − 40, and solves to obtain P = $24.
    • Substitutes to obtain the equilibrium quantity Q = 104.
    • Substitutes the ceiling P = 15 into the demand equation: Qd = 200 − 4(15) = 140.
    • Substitutes P = 15 into the supply equation: Qs = 6(15) − 40 = 50.
    • Calculates the shortage as Qd − Qs = 140 − 50 = 90 units.

    Examiner tip: A price ceiling only has an effect if it is set below the free-market equilibrium price — always check this first, since a ceiling set above equilibrium would be non-binding and change nothing.

  2. 2.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “In a market, demand is Qd = 200 − 4P and supply is Qs = 6P − 40. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium price and quantity. (b) The government imposes a price ceiling of $15. Calculate the resulting quantity demanded, quantity supplied, and the size of the shortage.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets Qd = Qs: 200 − 4P = 6P − 40, and solves to obtain P = $24.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets Qd = Qs: 200 − 4P = 6P − 40, and solves to obtain P = $24.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes to obtain the equilibrium quantity Q = 104.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes the ceiling P = 15 into the demand equation: Qd = 200 − 4(15) = 140.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes P = 15 into the supply equation: Qs = 6(15) − 40 = 50.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the shortage as Qd − Qs = 140 − 50 = 90 units.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  3. 3.

    A market has demand Qd = 200 − 4P and supply Qs = 6P − 40, giving a free-market equilibrium price of $24. The government imposes a price floor at $30. Calculate the resulting surplus, and calculate the total cost to the government if it agrees to purchase the entire surplus at the floor price.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. At the $30 floor, Qd = 200 - 4(30) = 80 and Qs = 6(30) - 40 = 140, giving 60 surplus units.
    2. Buying every surplus unit costs government $30 x 60 = $1800, excluding any storage costs. Private buyers still purchase the other 80 units; government is not purchasing total production.

    Common mistake: Multiplying $30 by all 140 supplied units even though only the excess is purchased publicly.

    Marking points

    • Substitutes the floor P = 30 into the demand equation: Qd = 200 − 4(30) = 80.
    • Substitutes P = 30 into the supply equation: Qs = 6(30) − 40 = 140.
    • Calculates the surplus as Qs − Qd = 140 − 80 = 60 units.
    • Calculates the government's cost as the floor price multiplied by the surplus quantity: $30 × 60 = $1,800.

    Examiner tip: A price floor only has an effect if it is set above the free-market equilibrium price — this is the mirror image of a price ceiling, which only binds when set below equilibrium.

  4. 4.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A market has demand Qd = 200 − 4P and supply Qs = 6P − 40, giving a free-market equilibrium price of $24. The government imposes a price floor at $30. Calculate the resulting surplus, and calculate the total cost to the government if it agrees to purchase the entire surplus at the floor price.” Their response addresses only this point: “Substitutes the floor P = 30 into the demand equation: Qd = 200 − 4(30) = 80.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Substitutes the floor P = 30 into the demand equation: Qd = 200 − 4(30) = 80.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes P = 30 into the supply equation: Qs = 6(30) − 40 = 140.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the surplus as Qs − Qd = 140 − 80 = 60 units.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the government's cost as the floor price multiplied by the surplus quantity: $30 × 60 = $1,800.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  5. 5.

    In a market, demand is Qd = 100 − 2P and supply is Qs = 3P − 20. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium price and quantity. (b) The government imposes a specific tax of $5 per unit on producers, so the new supply curve becomes Qs = 3(P − 5) − 20. Calculate the new equilibrium price paid by consumers, the price received by producers (after tax), and the new equilibrium quantity.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Without tax, 100 - 2P = 3P - 20 gives P = $24 and Q = 52. With tax, producers retain P - 5, so supply is 3(P - 5) - 20 = 3P - 35.
    2. Equalising gives 100 - 2P = 3P - 35, hence consumer P = $27 and Q = 46. Producers receive $27 - $5 = $22; their supply at $22 is also 46, checking both sides.

    Common mistake: Subtracting only $5 from the supply intercept instead of expanding 3(P - 5), which changes it by $15.

    Marking points

    • Sets Qd = Qs: 100 − 2P = 3P − 20, and solves to obtain the free-market equilibrium P = $24, Q = 52.
    • Sets up the new equation with the tax: 100 − 2P = 3P − 35.
    • Solves to obtain the new price paid by consumers: P = $27.
    • Calculates the price received by producers as P − 5 = $22.
    • Substitutes P = 27 into the demand equation to obtain the new quantity: Qd = 100 − 2(27) = 46.

    Examiner tip: A specific tax imposed on producers shifts the entire supply curve vertically upward by the amount of the tax — solving the new equilibrium always uses this shifted supply curve, not the original one.

  6. 6.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “In a market, demand is Qd = 100 − 2P and supply is Qs = 3P − 20. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium price and quantity. (b) The government imposes a specific tax of $5 per unit on producers, so the new supply curve becomes Qs = 3(P − 5) − 20. Calculate the new equilibrium price paid by consumers, the price received by producers (after tax), and the new equilibrium quantity.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets Qd = Qs: 100 − 2P = 3P − 20, and solves to obtain the free-market equilibrium P = $24, Q = 52.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets Qd = Qs: 100 − 2P = 3P − 20, and solves to obtain the free-market equilibrium P = $24, Q = 52.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Sets up the new equation with the tax: 100 − 2P = 3P − 35.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Solves to obtain the new price paid by consumers: P = $27.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the price received by producers as P − 5 = $22.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes P = 27 into the demand equation to obtain the new quantity: Qd = 100 − 2(27) = 46.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  7. 7.

    Demand is Qd = 100 - 2P and supply is Qs = 3P - 20. Before a $5 per-unit tax, P = $24 and Q = 52; afterwards consumers pay $27 and producers retain $22. Calculate the point price elasticities of demand and supply at the original equilibrium. Use them to explain why consumers bear $3 per unit of the tax and producers $2.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. At P = 24 and Q = 52, point PED = -2(24/52) = -0.923 and PES = 3(24/52) = 1.385. Demand is less elastic in magnitude.
    2. Consumer price rises $27 - $24 = $3 while producer receipt falls $24 - $22 = $2. Their shares are 60% and 40%; for these linear curves, 1.385/(1.385 + 0.923) = 0.60 confirms why less responsive buyers bear more.

    Common mistake: Comparing the signed negative demand elasticity with supply rather than comparing their magnitudes.

    Marking points

    • Calculates the price elasticity of demand at the original equilibrium (P = 24, Q = 52) using the demand slope of −2: Ed = −2 × (24/52) ≈ −0.92.
    • Calculates the price elasticity of supply at the same point using the supply slope of 3: Es = 3 × (24/52) ≈ 1.38.
    • States that demand (|Ed| ≈ 0.92) is relatively less elastic than supply (Es ≈ 1.38) at this point.
    • Concludes that the side of the market with the less elastic response (consumers, in this case) bears the larger share of the tax burden, consistent with the general tax incidence rule.

    Examiner tip: This calculation confirms the general rule with real numbers: tax burden always falls more heavily on whichever side of the market (consumers or producers) is relatively less price elastic at the equilibrium point.

  8. 8.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Demand is Qd = 100 - 2P and supply is Qs = 3P - 20. Before a $5 per-unit tax, P = $24 and Q = 52; afterwards consumers pay $27 and producers retain $22. Calculate the point price elasticities of demand and supply at the original equilibrium. Use them to explain why consumers bear $3 per unit of the tax and producers $2.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates the price elasticity of demand at the original equilibrium (P = 24, Q = 52) using the demand slope of −2: Ed = −2 × (24/52) ≈ −0.92.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates the price elasticity of demand at the original equilibrium (P = 24, Q = 52) using the demand slope of −2: Ed = −2 × (24/52) ≈ −0.92.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the price elasticity of supply at the same point using the supply slope of 3: Es = 3 × (24/52) ≈ 1.38.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that demand (|Ed| ≈ 0.92) is relatively less elastic than supply (Es ≈ 1.38) at this point.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that the side of the market with the less elastic response (consumers, in this case) bears the larger share of the tax burden, consistent with the general tax incidence rule.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  9. 9.

    Using the tax scenario from two questions ago (pre-tax equilibrium Q = 52; post-tax equilibrium Q = 46; tax = $5 per unit), calculate (a) the government's tax revenue, and (b) the deadweight welfare loss created by the tax.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. The $5 tax is collected on 46 surviving trades: revenue = $5 x 46 = $230.
    2. The six lost trades create a triangular loss under the linear no-externality model: 0.5 x $5 x (52 - 46) = $15. The $230 is transferred to government, whereas the $15 consists of gains from trade no longer realised.

    Common mistake: Counting all consumer surplus lost as deadweight loss, including the portion transferred as tax revenue.

    Marking points

    • Calculates tax revenue as the tax per unit multiplied by the new (post-tax) quantity: $5 × 46 = $230.
    • Uses the deadweight loss formula for a linear market: DWL = (1/2) × tax × (change in quantity).
    • Calculates the change in quantity as 52 − 46 = 6 units.
    • Calculates the deadweight loss as (1/2) × 5 × 6 = $15.

    Examiner tip: The deadweight loss triangle's base is always the fall in quantity traded due to the tax, and its height is always the tax per unit — this simple triangle-area formula works whenever supply and demand are linear.

  10. 10.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Using the tax scenario from two questions ago (pre-tax equilibrium Q = 52; post-tax equilibrium Q = 46; tax = $5 per unit), calculate (a) the government's tax revenue, and (b) the deadweight welfare loss created by the tax.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates tax revenue as the tax per unit multiplied by the new (post-tax) quantity: $5 × 46 = $230.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates tax revenue as the tax per unit multiplied by the new (post-tax) quantity: $5 × 46 = $230.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Uses the deadweight loss formula for a linear market: DWL = (1/2) × tax × (change in quantity).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the change in quantity as 52 − 46 = 6 units.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the deadweight loss as (1/2) × 5 × 6 = $15.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  11. 11.

    In the market Qd = 100 − 2P, Qs = 3P − 20 (free-market equilibrium P = $24, Q = 52), the government instead provides a subsidy of $5 per unit to producers, so the new supply curve becomes Qs = 3(P + 5) − 20. Calculate the new equilibrium price paid by consumers, the price received by producers (including the subsidy), the new quantity, and the total cost of the subsidy to the government.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Producers now receive P + 5, so 100 - 2P = 3(P + 5) - 20 = 3P - 5. Solving gives buyer P = $21 and Q = 58.
    2. Producer receipt is $21 + $5 = $26, consistent with original supply 3(26) - 20 = 58. Government cost is $5 x 58 = $290; payment covers every subsidised unit, not just the extra six.

    Common mistake: Using $21 as the producer receipt, leaving out the subsidy transfer.

    Marking points

    • Sets up the new equation with the subsidy: 100 − 2P = 3P − 5.
    • Solves to obtain the new price paid by consumers: P = $21.
    • Calculates the price received by producers as P + 5 = $26.
    • Substitutes P = 21 into the demand equation to obtain the new quantity: Qd = 100 − 2(21) = 58.
    • Calculates the total subsidy cost as the subsidy per unit multiplied by the new quantity: $5 × 58 = $290.

    Examiner tip: A subsidy works exactly like a tax in reverse: it shifts the supply curve vertically downward by the subsidy amount, lowering the price paid by consumers while raising the effective price received by producers.

  12. 12.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “In the market Qd = 100 − 2P, Qs = 3P − 20 (free-market equilibrium P = $24, Q = 52), the government instead provides a subsidy of $5 per unit to producers, so the new supply curve becomes Qs = 3(P + 5) − 20. Calculate the new equilibrium price paid by consumers, the price received by producers (including the subsidy), the new quantity, and the total cost of the subsidy to the government.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets up the new equation with the subsidy: 100 − 2P = 3P − 5.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets up the new equation with the subsidy: 100 − 2P = 3P − 5.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Solves to obtain the new price paid by consumers: P = $21.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the price received by producers as P + 5 = $26.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes P = 21 into the demand equation to obtain the new quantity: Qd = 100 − 2(21) = 58.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the total subsidy cost as the subsidy per unit multiplied by the new quantity: $5 × 58 = $290.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  13. 13.

    In a labor market, labor demand is Ld = 100 − 2W and labor supply is Ls = 3W − 50, where W is the hourly wage. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium wage and level of employment. (b) The government sets a minimum wage of $40. Calculate the resulting quantity of labor demanded, quantity supplied, and the size of the resulting unemployment.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. 100 - 2W = 3W - 50 gives W = $30/hour and L = 40 in the stated labour units.
    2. At the binding $40 floor, Ld = 100 - 80 = 20 and Ls = 120 - 50 = 70, so excess labour supply is 50. The loss of employment from equilibrium is only 40 - 20 = 20: additional jobseekers account for the rest of the gap.

    Common mistake: Calling all 50 unemployed units jobs destroyed; some reflect increased willingness to work at the higher wage.

    Marking points

    • Sets Ld = Ls: 100 − 2W = 3W − 50, and solves to obtain the free-market wage W = $30 and employment L = 40.
    • Substitutes the minimum wage W = 40 into the labor demand equation: Ld = 100 − 2(40) = 20.
    • Substitutes W = 40 into the labor supply equation: Ls = 3(40) − 50 = 70.
    • Calculates the resulting unemployment as Ls − Ld = 70 − 20 = 50.

    Examiner tip: A minimum wage is simply a price floor applied to the labor market — the mechanics of calculating the resulting surplus (here, unemployment) are identical to a price floor in a goods market.

  14. 14.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “In a labor market, labor demand is Ld = 100 − 2W and labor supply is Ls = 3W − 50, where W is the hourly wage. (a) Calculate the free-market equilibrium wage and level of employment. (b) The government sets a minimum wage of $40. Calculate the resulting quantity of labor demanded, quantity supplied, and the size of the resulting unemployment.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets Ld = Ls: 100 − 2W = 3W − 50, and solves to obtain the free-market wage W = $30 and employment L = 40.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets Ld = Ls: 100 − 2W = 3W − 50, and solves to obtain the free-market wage W = $30 and employment L = 40.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes the minimum wage W = 40 into the labor demand equation: Ld = 100 − 2(40) = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes W = 40 into the labor supply equation: Ls = 3(40) − 50 = 70.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the resulting unemployment as Ls − Ld = 70 − 20 = 50.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  15. 15.

    Explain why a minimum wage set in a monopsony labor market (a market with a single dominant employer) might increase employment, in contrast to the usual prediction that a minimum wage causes unemployment in a competitive labor market.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Optional enrichment

    Syllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022, updated October 2022; 2.7, pp.29-30; 2.11, pp.31-33 (printed pages). Monopsony marginal-hiring-cost analysis exceeds prescribed wage-floor and product-market models.

    Worked explanation

    1. A single wage-setting employer must raise the wage to attract extra labour, including on existing workers in the uniform-wage model. Its marginal labour cost therefore exceeds the wage, encouraging restricted hiring.
    2. A suitably placed wage floor makes the cost of an additional worker equal to the mandated wage over the relevant supply segment. This can remove the extra marginal cost from raising all existing wages and make more hiring profitable; a floor set too high will instead reduce demand.

    Common mistake: Applying the competitive price-floor unemployment result without checking the monopsonist's marginal labour cost.

    Marking points

    • States that a monopsony employer, having wage-setting power, pays a wage below the competitive level and hires below the competitive level of employment, since its marginal cost of labor exceeds the wage it pays.
    • Explains that a minimum wage set between the monopsony wage and the competitive wage effectively becomes the employer's new marginal cost of labor for all workers up to that wage, removing the employer's incentive to restrict hiring to keep the wage low.
    • Concludes that within this range, the employer can be induced to hire more workers at the higher, legally mandated wage than it would voluntarily choose to hire at its own profit-maximizing (lower) monopsony wage.

    Examiner tip: A suitable minimum wage can increase employment in the standard monopsony model. In the competitive model, a floor creates excess labour supply only when it is binding; neither prediction applies unconditionally to all labour markets.

  16. 16.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why a minimum wage set in a monopsony labor market (a market with a single dominant employer) might increase employment, in contrast to the usual prediction that a minimum wage causes unemployment in a competitive labor market.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that a monopsony employer, having wage-setting power, pays a wage below the competitive level and hires below the competitive level of employment, since its marginal cost of labor exceeds the wage it pays.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that a monopsony employer, having wage-setting power, pays a wage below the competitive level and hires below the competitive level of employment, since its marginal cost of labor exceeds the wage it pays.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that a minimum wage set between the monopsony wage and the competitive wage effectively becomes the employer's new marginal cost of labor for all workers up to that wage, removing the employer's incentive to restrict hiring to keep the wage low.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that within this range, the employer can be induced to hire more workers at the higher, legally mandated wage than it would voluntarily choose to hire at its own profit-maximizing (lower) monopsony wage.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  17. 17.

    A monopsony employer faces a labor supply curve of W = 10 + 0.5L (so its marginal cost of labor is MCL = 10 + L) and a labor demand (marginal revenue product) curve of MRP = 50 − L. (a) Calculate the employment level and wage the monopsonist chooses, where MRP = MCL. (b) Calculate the employment level and wage that would occur if the market were instead perfectly competitive, where MRP = W (the supply curve).

    [5 marks]

    Course scope: Optional enrichment

    Syllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022, updated October 2022; 2.7, pp.29-30; 2.11, pp.31-33 (printed pages). MRP=MCL labour optimisation exceeds the prescribed wage-floor/product-market calculations.

    Worked explanation

    1. Monopsony sets MRP = MCL: 50 - L = 10 + L, giving L = 20. Read the wage from supply, not MCL: W = 10 + 0.5(20) = $20.
    2. Competition instead uses MRP = W: 50 - L = 10 + 0.5L, giving L = 26.6667 and W = $23.33. Monopsony restricts labour below this benchmark and pays less; its $30 marginal hiring cost at L = 20 is not its wage.

    Common mistake: Reporting the MCL value $30 as the wage instead of using the supply curve.

    Marking points

    • Sets MRP = MCL: 50 − L = 10 + L, and solves to obtain the monopsony employment level L = 20.
    • Substitutes L = 20 into the supply curve to obtain the monopsony wage: W = 10 + 0.5(20) = $20.
    • Sets MRP = W (the competitive condition): 50 − L = 10 + 0.5L, and solves to obtain the competitive employment level L ≈ 26.7.
    • Substitutes to obtain the competitive wage: W = 10 + 0.5(26.7) ≈ $23.33.
    • Concludes that the monopsonist hires fewer workers (20 versus 26.7) at a lower wage ($20 versus $23.33) than a perfectly competitive labor market would produce.

    Examiner tip: The key distinction for a monopsonist is that its marginal cost of labor curve lies above its labor supply curve (since hiring one more worker requires raising the wage paid to all workers), unlike a wage-taking firm where the supply curve and MCL curve are identical.

  18. 18.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A monopsony employer faces a labor supply curve of W = 10 + 0.5L (so its marginal cost of labor is MCL = 10 + L) and a labor demand (marginal revenue product) curve of MRP = 50 − L. (a) Calculate the employment level and wage the monopsonist chooses, where MRP = MCL. (b) Calculate the employment level and wage that would occur if the market were instead perfectly competitive, where MRP = W (the supply curve).” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets MRP = MCL: 50 − L = 10 + L, and solves to obtain the monopsony employment level L = 20.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets MRP = MCL: 50 − L = 10 + L, and solves to obtain the monopsony employment level L = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes L = 20 into the supply curve to obtain the monopsony wage: W = 10 + 0.5(20) = $20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Sets MRP = W (the competitive condition): 50 − L = 10 + 0.5L, and solves to obtain the competitive employment level L ≈ 26.7.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes to obtain the competitive wage: W = 10 + 0.5(26.7) ≈ $23.33.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that the monopsonist hires fewer workers (20 versus 26.7) at a lower wage ($20 versus $23.33) than a perfectly competitive labor market would produce.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  19. 19.

    Two firms must each reduce their pollution, with a combined required reduction of 30 units. Firm A's marginal abatement cost is MAC_A = 2Q_A (where Q_A is units reduced by Firm A), and Firm B's marginal abatement cost is MAC_B = Q_B. Calculate the cost-minimizing allocation of the 30-unit reduction between the two firms, where MAC_A = MAC_B, and state the resulting market price of a tradeable pollution permit.

    [5 marks]

    Course scope: Optional enrichment

    Syllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022, updated October 2022; 2.8, pp.30-31 (printed pages). Marginal-abatement optimisation exceeds the listed permit explanation and welfare-loss calculation.

    Worked explanation

    1. Cheapest combined abatement requires equal marginal costs: 2QA = QB, with QA + QB = 30. Substituting gives 3QA = 30, so A cuts 10 units and B cuts 20.
    2. Both marginal costs are then $20 per unit, the competitive permit-price benchmark. Asking both to cut 15 would leave A's last cut costing $30 and B's $15; shifting some reduction from A to B would save resources.

    Common mistake: Dividing the required reduction equally, ignoring firms' different marginal abatement costs.

    Marking points

    • Sets up the condition for cost-minimization: MAC_A = MAC_B, giving 2Q_A = Q_B.
    • Uses the total reduction constraint: Q_A + Q_B = 30.
    • Substitutes Q_B = 2Q_A into the constraint: Q_A + 2Q_A = 30, giving Q_A = 10.
    • Calculates Q_B = 30 − 10 = 20.
    • States the resulting permit price as MAC_A = 2(10) = $20 (equal to MAC_B = 20, confirming the allocation is cost-minimizing).

    Examiner tip: A tradeable permit market naturally achieves this cost-minimizing allocation without a regulator needing to calculate it directly: firms with higher abatement costs will buy permits from firms that can reduce pollution more cheaply, until marginal abatement costs are equalised.

  20. 20.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Two firms must each reduce their pollution, with a combined required reduction of 30 units. Firm A's marginal abatement cost is MAC_A = 2Q_A (where Q_A is units reduced by Firm A), and Firm B's marginal abatement cost is MAC_B = Q_B. Calculate the cost-minimizing allocation of the 30-unit reduction between the two firms, where MAC_A = MAC_B, and state the resulting market price of a tradeable pollution permit.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets up the condition for cost-minimization: MAC_A = MAC_B, giving 2Q_A = Q_B.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets up the condition for cost-minimization: MAC_A = MAC_B, giving 2Q_A = Q_B.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Uses the total reduction constraint: Q_A + Q_B = 30.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes Q_B = 2Q_A into the constraint: Q_A + 2Q_A = 30, giving Q_A = 10.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates Q_B = 30 − 10 = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States the resulting permit price as MAC_A = 2(10) = $20 (equal to MAC_B = 20, confirming the allocation is cost-minimizing).

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  21. 21.

    Explain the 'free rider problem' associated with public goods, and explain why this problem means a free market will tend to under-provide public goods such as national defense or street lighting.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Street lighting cannot readily exclude a non-paying passer-by, and another person using its light does not use it up. Non-excludability encourages free riding; non-rivalry is a separate property.
    2. If residents can enjoy light without contributing, a private supplier may collect too little voluntary revenue to cover installation. Compulsory tax finance can solve this funding problem, while construction can still be contracted to a private company.

    Common mistake: Saying non-rivalry alone prevents charging; the non-exclusion problem drives free riding.

    Marking points

    • States that public goods are non-excludable (once provided, no one can be prevented from consuming them) and non-rivalrous (one person's consumption does not reduce the amount available to others).
    • Explains that because the good is non-excludable, individuals have an incentive to 'free ride' by benefiting from the good without paying for it, since they cannot be prevented from using it anyway.
    • Explains that if enough people free ride, private firms cannot generate enough revenue from voluntary payment to cover the cost of providing the good, so profit-seeking firms choose not to supply it, or supply too little of it.
    • Concludes that this market failure justifies government provision of public goods, funded through compulsory taxation rather than voluntary payment.

    Examiner tip: Non-excludability is the root cause of the free rider problem, while non-rivalry is the separate property that explains why, once the good is provided, it is efficient for everyone to consume it — keep these two properties distinct in your explanation.

  22. 22.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain the 'free rider problem' associated with public goods, and explain why this problem means a free market will tend to under-provide public goods such as national defense or street lighting.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that public goods are non-excludable (once provided, no one can be prevented from consuming them) and non-rivalrous (one person's consumption does not reduce the amount available to others).” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that public goods are non-excludable (once provided, no one can be prevented from consuming them) and non-rivalrous (one person's consumption does not reduce the amount available to others).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that because the good is non-excludable, individuals have an incentive to 'free ride' by benefiting from the good without paying for it, since they cannot be prevented from using it anyway.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that if enough people free ride, private firms cannot generate enough revenue from voluntary payment to cover the cost of providing the good, so profit-seeking firms choose not to supply it, or supply too little of it.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that this market failure justifies government provision of public goods, funded through compulsory taxation rather than voluntary payment.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  23. 23.

    Explain how imperfect information can lead to under-consumption of a merit good such as preventative healthcare, and state one government policy that could address this specific cause.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A patient who underestimates the future health benefit of screening may reject a test even when its informed private benefit exceeds its price. This is under-consumption due to imperfect information, independent of benefits to other people.
    2. An evidence-based information campaign explaining screening outcomes can raise perceived benefit toward informed benefit. Subsidising a test can alter its price, but does not by itself correct the mistaken belief that the test is useless.

    Common mistake: Explaining only positive externalities when the question specifically asks about underestimated private benefits.

    Marking points

    • Explains that consumers may underestimate the future private benefits of a merit good (such as the long-term health benefits of preventative care) because they lack full information about these benefits at the time of the consumption decision.
    • Explains that this leads consumers to value the good less than its true, fully-informed value, causing them to demand and consume less than the socially optimal quantity.
    • States a valid policy response that directly addresses the information gap, such as a public information or education campaign about the benefits of preventative healthcare, rather than only a tax or subsidy.

    Examiner tip: Information failure is a distinct cause of under-consumption from a positive externality, even though both merit good arguments often get discussed together — information campaigns address the former, while subsidies address the latter.

  24. 24.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain how imperfect information can lead to under-consumption of a merit good such as preventative healthcare, and state one government policy that could address this specific cause.” Their response addresses only this point: “Explains that consumers may underestimate the future private benefits of a merit good (such as the long-term health benefits of preventative care) because they lack full information about these benefits at the time of the consumption decision.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Explains that consumers may underestimate the future private benefits of a merit good (such as the long-term health benefits of preventative care) because they lack full information about these benefits at the time of the consumption decision.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that this leads consumers to value the good less than its true, fully-informed value, causing them to demand and consume less than the socially optimal quantity.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States a valid policy response that directly addresses the information gap, such as a public information or education campaign about the benefits of preventative healthcare, rather than only a tax or subsidy.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  25. 25.

    Explain the concept of 'government failure', using the example of agricultural price supports that create persistent, costly surpluses that must be stored or destroyed.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. An agricultural floor above equilibrium rewards extra output while discouraging purchases, leaving a persistent surplus that government buys, stores or destroys.
    2. Storage and disposal consume resources that could provide other services, while food buyers face higher prices. If those net welfare costs exceed the policy's benefits relative to the relevant alternative, it is government failure; a spending bill alone does not establish that comparison.

    Common mistake: Defining government failure as any policy with a cost instead of a net worsening relative to an alternative.

    Marking points

    • States that government failure occurs when intervention reduces economic welfare relative to the relevant no-intervention alternative, for example because its costs exceed its benefits. The intervention need not have been introduced specifically to correct a market failure.
    • Explains that an agricultural price floor set above the equilibrium price creates a persistent surplus, since quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded at that price.
    • Explains that the government then bears the ongoing cost of storing or destroying this surplus, which represents a waste of resources (an opportunity cost) that could have been avoided without the price support, while also keeping food prices artificially high for consumers.

    Examiner tip: Government failure does not mean intervention is always bad — it means a specific policy's unintended costs can exceed its intended benefits, which is why cost-benefit analysis of any intervention is important before and after implementation.

  26. 26.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain the concept of 'government failure', using the example of agricultural price supports that create persistent, costly surpluses that must be stored or destroyed.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that government failure occurs when intervention reduces economic welfare relative to the relevant no-intervention alternative, for example because its costs exceed its benefits. The intervention need not have been introduced specifically to correct a market failure.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that government failure occurs when intervention reduces economic welfare relative to the relevant no-intervention alternative, for example because its costs exceed its benefits. The intervention need not have been introduced specifically to correct a market failure.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that an agricultural price floor set above the equilibrium price creates a persistent surplus, since quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded at that price.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that the government then bears the ongoing cost of storing or destroying this surplus, which represents a waste of resources (an opportunity cost) that could have been avoided without the price support, while also keeping food prices artificially high for consumers.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  27. 27.

    A government is deciding between a flat (lump-sum) tax of $500 on every income earner and a progressive income tax. Taxpayer A earns $5,000 per year, and Taxpayer B earns $50,000 per year. (a) Calculate the flat tax as a percentage of each taxpayer's income. (b) Explain whether the flat tax is regressive, proportional, or progressive, based on your calculation.

    [3 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. A pays $500/$5000 x 100 = 10% of income; B pays $500/$50000 x 100 = 1%. The cash payment is identical but the relative sacrifice differs.
    2. Since average tax rate falls as income rises, this lump-sum tax is regressive, not proportional. It should not be confused with a flat percentage income tax, whose dollar payment rises proportionally with income.

    Common mistake: Calling a fixed-dollar tax proportional merely because everyone pays the same amount.

    Marking points

    • Calculates the tax as a percentage of Taxpayer A's income: 500/5,000 × 100 = 10%.
    • Calculates the tax as a percentage of Taxpayer B's income: 500/50,000 × 100 = 1%.
    • States that since the tax takes a smaller percentage of income from the higher earner (1%) than the lower earner (10%), the flat tax is regressive.

    Examiner tip: A tax is regressive, proportional, or progressive based on whether the percentage of income paid falls, stays the same, or rises as income increases — a fixed dollar amount is always regressive, since it is a larger share of a smaller income.

  28. 28.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A government is deciding between a flat (lump-sum) tax of $500 on every income earner and a progressive income tax. Taxpayer A earns $5,000 per year, and Taxpayer B earns $50,000 per year. (a) Calculate the flat tax as a percentage of each taxpayer's income. (b) Explain whether the flat tax is regressive, proportional, or progressive, based on your calculation.” Their response addresses only this point: “Calculates the tax as a percentage of Taxpayer A's income: 500/5,000 × 100 = 10%.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Calculates the tax as a percentage of Taxpayer A's income: 500/5,000 × 100 = 10%.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates the tax as a percentage of Taxpayer B's income: 500/50,000 × 100 = 1%.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that since the tax takes a smaller percentage of income from the higher earner (1%) than the lower earner (10%), the flat tax is regressive.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  29. 29.

    Marginal private cost is MPC = 10 + Q and marginal external cost is a constant $5 per unit, so MSC = 15 + Q. There are no consumption externalities: MPB = MSB = 50 - Q. (a) Calculate free-market equilibrium quantity. (b) Calculate socially optimal quantity. (c) State the Pigouvian tax per unit that corrects the production externality.

    [4 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Private equilibrium ignores external cost: 10 + Q = 50 - Q gives Q = 20. Social efficiency instead uses 15 + Q = 50 - Q, giving Q = 17.5.
    2. A $5/unit Pigouvian tax makes private supply cost equal to MSC and removes the 2.5-unit overproduction. Here MEC is constant, so its value at the social optimum is $5; average damage need not generally equal the corrective marginal charge.

    Common mistake: Setting the tax equal to the 2.5-unit output gap, confusing a quantity correction with a dollar-per-unit incentive.

    Marking points

    • Sets MPC = MSB: 10 + Q = 50 − Q, and solves to obtain the free-market quantity Q = 20.
    • Sets MSC = MSB: 15 + Q = 50 − Q, and solves to obtain the socially optimal quantity Q = 17.5.
    • States that the free market overproduces (Q = 20) relative to the social optimum (Q = 17.5), consistent with a negative externality.
    • States that the Pigouvian tax should equal the marginal external cost at the socially optimal output, which is the constant $5 per unit, so that MPC + tax = MSC.

    Examiner tip: A Pigouvian tax set exactly equal to the marginal external cost makes the polluter 'internalize' the externality, since MPC plus the tax becomes identical to MSC — this shifts the market equilibrium exactly to the socially optimal quantity.

  30. 30.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Marginal private cost is MPC = 10 + Q and marginal external cost is a constant $5 per unit, so MSC = 15 + Q. There are no consumption externalities: MPB = MSB = 50 - Q. (a) Calculate free-market equilibrium quantity. (b) Calculate socially optimal quantity. (c) State the Pigouvian tax per unit that corrects the production externality.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets MPC = MSB: 10 + Q = 50 − Q, and solves to obtain the free-market quantity Q = 20.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets MPC = MSB: 10 + Q = 50 − Q, and solves to obtain the free-market quantity Q = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Sets MSC = MSB: 15 + Q = 50 − Q, and solves to obtain the socially optimal quantity Q = 17.5.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that the free market overproduces (Q = 20) relative to the social optimum (Q = 17.5), consistent with a negative externality.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that the Pigouvian tax should equal the marginal external cost at the socially optimal output, which is the constant $5 per unit, so that MPC + tax = MSC.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.