IB · ECON HL

Economics HL

Microeconomics HL: market structures — Unit 2 HL

Name: ____________________Date: November 19, 2026
  1. 1.

    A perfectly competitive firm faces a market price of $15 per unit. Its total cost function is TC = Q² + 2Q + 10, giving a marginal cost of MC = 2Q + 2. (a) Calculate the profit-maximizing output level, where P = MC. (b) Calculate the firm's total revenue, total cost, and profit at this output.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. A price-taking firm has MR = P = $15. Solve 15 = 2Q + 2 to get Q = 6.5 units, assuming divisible output and rising MC.
    2. TR = 15 x 6.5 = $97.50; TC = 6.5 squared + 2(6.5) + 10 = $65.25; profit = $32.25. AVC = Q + 2 = $8.50 is below price, so operating covers variable costs and is preferable to shutting down.

    Common mistake: Rounding output to an integer before calculating profit despite the continuous model.

    Marking points

    • Sets P = MC: 15 = 2Q + 2.
    • Solves to obtain Q = 6.5 units.
    • Calculates total revenue as P × Q = 15 × 6.5 = $97.50.
    • Calculates total cost as 6.5² + 2(6.5) + 10 = $65.25.
    • Calculates profit as TR − TC = 97.50 − 65.25 = $32.25.

    Examiner tip: For an interior operating optimum, a competitive firm equates price to rising marginal cost, then checks that operating is preferable to shutting down. Here P exceeds average variable cost at Q = 6.5.

  2. 2.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A perfectly competitive firm faces a market price of $15 per unit. Its total cost function is TC = Q² + 2Q + 10, giving a marginal cost of MC = 2Q + 2. (a) Calculate the profit-maximizing output level, where P = MC. (b) Calculate the firm's total revenue, total cost, and profit at this output.” Their response addresses only this point: “Sets P = MC: 15 = 2Q + 2.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Sets P = MC: 15 = 2Q + 2.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Solves to obtain Q = 6.5 units.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates total revenue as P × Q = 15 × 6.5 = $97.50.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates total cost as 6.5² + 2(6.5) + 10 = $65.25.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates profit as TR − TC = 97.50 − 65.25 = $32.25.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  3. 3.

    Explain why a perfectly competitive firm can earn supernormal profit in the short run but only normal profit in the long run.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Short-run price above average economic cost leaves supernormal profit, signalling an attractive return to potential entrants.
    2. With free entry, new firms expand industry supply and lower market price until an efficient firm's price equals minimum average cost. Normal profit remains as the opportunity-cost return already included in economic costs; it is not zero accounting profit.

    Common mistake: Interpreting normal profit as owners receiving no return at all.

    Marking points

    • States that if existing firms are earning supernormal profit in the short run, this acts as a signal attracting new firms to enter the industry, since there are no significant barriers to entry.
    • Explains that as new firms enter, market supply increases, shifting the market supply curve to the right and lowering the market price.
    • Explains that entry continues until the price falls to the level of each firm's minimum average cost, at which point supernormal profit is competed away and only normal profit remains, removing any further incentive to enter.

    Examiner tip: Free entry and exit is the key assumption driving this result — it is precisely why perfect competition cannot sustain supernormal profit in the long run, unlike monopoly.

  4. 4.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why a perfectly competitive firm can earn supernormal profit in the short run but only normal profit in the long run.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that if existing firms are earning supernormal profit in the short run, this acts as a signal attracting new firms to enter the industry, since there are no significant barriers to entry.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that if existing firms are earning supernormal profit in the short run, this acts as a signal attracting new firms to enter the industry, since there are no significant barriers to entry.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that as new firms enter, market supply increases, shifting the market supply curve to the right and lowering the market price.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that entry continues until the price falls to the level of each firm's minimum average cost, at which point supernormal profit is competed away and only normal profit remains, removing any further incentive to enter.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  5. 5.

    A monopolist faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and has a constant marginal cost of MC = 20. (a) Derive the marginal revenue function. (b) Calculate the profit-maximizing output and price, where MR = MC. (c) Calculate the monopolist's profit, assuming no fixed costs.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. TR = PQ = (100 - 2Q)Q = 100Q - 2Q squared, so MR = 100 - 4Q. Setting MR = MC gives 100 - 4Q = 20, hence Q = 20.
    2. Read price from demand: P = 100 - 2(20) = $60. With no fixed costs and MC constant at $20, TR = $1200, TC = $400 and profit = $800. Charging $20 would confuse marginal revenue with the price buyers pay.

    Common mistake: Using the $20 MR value as monopoly price rather than returning to the demand equation.

    Marking points

    • States total revenue TR = PQ = (100 − 2Q)Q = 100Q − 2Q².
    • Differentiates to obtain MR = 100 − 4Q.
    • Sets MR = MC: 100 − 4Q = 20, and solves to obtain Q = 20.
    • Substitutes Q = 20 into the demand equation to obtain P = 100 − 2(20) = $60.
    • Calculates profit as (P − MC) × Q = (60 − 20) × 20 = $800.

    Examiner tip: The monopolist's marginal revenue curve always has twice the slope of a linear demand curve — notice that MR = 100 − 4Q falls twice as fast as the demand curve P = 100 − 2Q.

  6. 6.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A monopolist faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and has a constant marginal cost of MC = 20. (a) Derive the marginal revenue function. (b) Calculate the profit-maximizing output and price, where MR = MC. (c) Calculate the monopolist's profit, assuming no fixed costs.” Their response addresses only this point: “States total revenue TR = PQ = (100 − 2Q)Q = 100Q − 2Q².” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States total revenue TR = PQ = (100 − 2Q)Q = 100Q − 2Q².
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Differentiates to obtain MR = 100 − 4Q.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Sets MR = MC: 100 − 4Q = 20, and solves to obtain Q = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Substitutes Q = 20 into the demand equation to obtain P = 100 − 2(20) = $60.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates profit as (P − MC) × Q = (60 − 20) × 20 = $800.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  7. 7.

    A monopoly faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and constant marginal cost MC = 20, and it maximises profit at Q = 20, P = 60. Explain why this monopoly outcome is allocatively inefficient compared to a perfectly competitive outcome in the same market.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. The efficient benchmark equates demand to MC: 100 - 2Q = 20 gives Q = 40 at P = $20, rather than monopoly's Q = 20 and P = $60.
    2. For units between 20 and 40, willingness to pay exceeds the $20 resource cost, yet monopoly excludes them to protect revenue on other units. Their forgone net benefit is deadweight loss; the linear triangle is 0.5 x 20 x 40 = $400, distinct from monopoly profit.

    Common mistake: Identifying the $800 monopoly profit itself as the welfare loss rather than a surplus distribution outcome.

    Marking points

    • States that allocative efficiency requires price to equal marginal cost (P = MC).
    • Calculates that under perfect competition, P = MC would give 100 − 2Q = 20, so Q = 40 and P = $20 — a higher output and lower price than under monopoly.
    • Explains that the monopolist restricts output below this competitive level (Q = 20 instead of 40) and charges a price above marginal cost (P = 60 versus MC = 20) in order to maximize its own profit.
    • Concludes that this restriction creates a deadweight welfare loss, since some consumers who valued the good above its marginal cost of production are excluded from the market.

    Examiner tip: Reusing the same demand and cost functions to compare monopoly and perfect competition outcomes directly is a classic HL technique — it lets you quantify exactly how much output is 'missing' and why.

  8. 8.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A monopoly faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and constant marginal cost MC = 20, and it maximises profit at Q = 20, P = 60. Explain why this monopoly outcome is allocatively inefficient compared to a perfectly competitive outcome in the same market.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that allocative efficiency requires price to equal marginal cost (P = MC).” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that allocative efficiency requires price to equal marginal cost (P = MC).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates that under perfect competition, P = MC would give 100 − 2Q = 20, so Q = 40 and P = $20 — a higher output and lower price than under monopoly.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that the monopolist restricts output below this competitive level (Q = 20 instead of 40) and charges a price above marginal cost (P = 60 versus MC = 20) in order to maximize its own profit.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that this restriction creates a deadweight welfare loss, since some consumers who valued the good above its marginal cost of production are excluded from the market.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  9. 9.

    A firm can prevent resale between two separate markets: Market A has demand P_A = 50 - Q_A and Market B has demand P_B = 80 - 2Q_B. Marginal cost is a constant $10 per unit, fixed costs are zero, and output is divisible. (a) Calculate the profit-maximising price and quantity in each market. (b) Calculate total profit, showing revenue and cost in each market.

    [5 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Solve each group's MR = $10 separately. A: 50 - 2QA = 10 gives QA = 20 and PA = $30. B: 80 - 4QB = 10 gives QB = 17.5 and PB = $45.
    2. A revenue = $600 and cost = $200, so profit = $400. B revenue = $787.50 and cost = $175, so profit = $612.50. Total profit = $1012.50 with zero fixed cost and divisible quantities.
    3. The price gap can persist because resale is prevented. Equalising prices across the two markets would discard the opportunity to tailor output to their different demand responses.

    Common mistake: Adding market demands and imposing a single price even though resale prevention permits separate price choices.

    Marking points

    • Derives MR_A = 50 − 2Q_A and sets MR_A = MC: 50 − 2Q_A = 10, giving Q_A = 20 and P_A = 50 − 20 = $30.
    • Derives MR_B = 80 − 4Q_B and sets MR_B = MC: 80 − 4Q_B = 10, giving Q_B = 17.5 and P_B = 80 − 2(17.5) = $45.
    • Calculates revenues as $600 in A and $787.50 in B, and costs as $200 in A and $175 in B.
    • Calculates profit in Market A as (30 − 10) × 20 = $400, and profit in Market B as (45 − 10) × 17.5 = $612.50.
    • Calculates total profit as 400 + 612.50 = $1,012.50.

    Examiner tip: Third-degree price discrimination always sets a separate MR = MC condition in each market — solve each market completely independently before combining the results into a total profit.

  10. 10.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A firm can prevent resale between two separate markets: Market A has demand P_A = 50 - Q_A and Market B has demand P_B = 80 - 2Q_B. Marginal cost is a constant $10 per unit, fixed costs are zero, and output is divisible. (a) Calculate the profit-maximising price and quantity in each market. (b) Calculate total profit, showing revenue and cost in each market.” Their response addresses only this point: “Derives MR_A = 50 − 2Q_A and sets MR_A = MC: 50 − 2Q_A = 10, giving Q_A = 20 and P_A = 50 − 20 = $30.” Evaluate the response against the complete 5-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [5 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Derives MR_A = 50 − 2Q_A and sets MR_A = MC: 50 − 2Q_A = 10, giving Q_A = 20 and P_A = 50 − 20 = $30.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Derives MR_B = 80 − 4Q_B and sets MR_B = MC: 80 − 4Q_B = 10, giving Q_B = 17.5 and P_B = 80 − 2(17.5) = $45.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates revenues as $600 in A and $787.50 in B, and costs as $200 in A and $175 in B.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates profit in Market A as (30 − 10) × 20 = $400, and profit in Market B as (45 − 10) × 17.5 = $612.50.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Calculates total profit as 400 + 612.50 = $1,012.50.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  11. 11.

    State three conditions for a firm to practise third-degree price discrimination between separate customer groups.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. The firm needs price-setting power and a way to identify separate groups with different demand responsiveness; otherwise it cannot profitably impose distinct group prices.
    2. It must also stop cheap buyers reselling to expensive buyers, for example through non-transferable tickets. Without that third condition, arbitrage erodes the intended price gap even when groups initially differ.

    Common mistake: Giving only different elasticities as sufficient, overlooking market power and enforceable separation.

    Marking points

    • States that the firm must have some degree of market/monopoly power (the ability to set price above marginal cost).
    • States that the firm must be able to separate consumers into distinct groups, usually with different price elasticities of demand.
    • States that the firm must be able to prevent resale (arbitrage) between the groups, so that consumers who bought at the lower price cannot resell to consumers facing the higher price.

    Examiner tip: If resale between groups cannot be prevented, price discrimination collapses: buyers in the low-price market would simply resell to buyers in the high-price market, eliminating the price gap.

  12. 12.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “State three conditions for a firm to practise third-degree price discrimination between separate customer groups.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that the firm must have some degree of market/monopoly power (the ability to set price above marginal cost).” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that the firm must have some degree of market/monopoly power (the ability to set price above marginal cost).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that the firm must be able to separate consumers into distinct groups, usually with different price elasticities of demand.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that the firm must be able to prevent resale (arbitrage) between the groups, so that consumers who bought at the lower price cannot resell to consumers facing the higher price.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  13. 13.

    Explain why a monopolistically competitive firm can earn supernormal profit in the short run but typically earns only normal profit in the long run, despite being able to differentiate its product.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Product differentiation allows some price-setting power and possible short-run profit, but low entry barriers let rival brands compete for the same customers.
    2. Each incumbent's demand shifts inward as consumers gain alternatives, eventually becoming tangent to average cost in the standard model. Price can still exceed MC at this zero-economic-profit point, so normal profit does not imply allocative efficiency.

    Common mistake: Assuming differentiation prevents entry or that long-run normal profit requires P = MC.

    Marking points

    • States that monopolistically competitive markets have low barriers to entry, similar to perfect competition.
    • Explains that short-run supernormal profit attracts new firms offering similar (but differentiated) products, increasing competition faced by the original firm.
    • Explains that as firms enter, each existing firm's demand curve shifts left (and becomes more elastic) as consumers have more substitute brands to choose from, reducing each firm's market share and price.
    • Concludes that entry continues until price falls to equal average cost, leaving only normal profit, even though each firm retains some limited pricing power from product differentiation.

    Examiner tip: The key difference from perfect competition is that the monopolistically competitive firm's long-run equilibrium occurs where price equals average cost but is still above marginal cost, since the demand curve it faces is downward sloping, not horizontal.

  14. 14.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why a monopolistically competitive firm can earn supernormal profit in the short run but typically earns only normal profit in the long run, despite being able to differentiate its product.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that monopolistically competitive markets have low barriers to entry, similar to perfect competition.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that monopolistically competitive markets have low barriers to entry, similar to perfect competition.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that short-run supernormal profit attracts new firms offering similar (but differentiated) products, increasing competition faced by the original firm.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that as firms enter, each existing firm's demand curve shifts left (and becomes more elastic) as consumers have more substitute brands to choose from, reducing each firm's market share and price.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that entry continues until price falls to equal average cost, leaving only normal profit, even though each firm retains some limited pricing power from product differentiation.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  15. 15.

    Explain the kinked demand curve model of oligopoly, and describe why it predicts that oligopolists are reluctant to change their prices.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. If rivals ignore a price increase, a firm loses many customers: demand above the current price is relatively elastic. If rivals match a cut, little extra share is gained: demand below is less elastic.
    2. The kink generates a gap in MR, so an MC movement within that gap need not change the chosen output or price. This explains possible price rigidity under those response assumptions, not how the original price was selected.

    Common mistake: Reversing rival responses or claiming the model determines the starting price.

    Marking points

    • States that the kinked demand curve assumes rival firms will match a price cut (to avoid losing market share) but will not match a price increase (to gain market share from the firm that raised its price).
    • Explains that this creates a relatively elastic demand curve above the current price (since a price rise is not matched, causing a large loss of customers) and a relatively inelastic demand curve below it (since a price cut is matched, so little is gained in market share).
    • Explains that this kink creates a discontinuity (vertical gap) in the marginal revenue curve, meaning marginal cost can shift within this gap without changing the profit-maximizing price, explaining observed price rigidity (price stickiness) in oligopolistic markets.

    Examiner tip: The kinked demand curve model explains price rigidity, but it does not explain how the initial price was set in the first place — it only describes why, once set, oligopolists resist changing it.

  16. 16.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain the kinked demand curve model of oligopoly, and describe why it predicts that oligopolists are reluctant to change their prices.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that the kinked demand curve assumes rival firms will match a price cut (to avoid losing market share) but will not match a price increase (to gain market share from the firm that raised its price).” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that the kinked demand curve assumes rival firms will match a price cut (to avoid losing market share) but will not match a price increase (to gain market share from the firm that raised its price).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that this creates a relatively elastic demand curve above the current price (since a price rise is not matched, causing a large loss of customers) and a relatively inelastic demand curve below it (since a price cut is matched, so little is gained in market share).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that this kink creates a discontinuity (vertical gap) in the marginal revenue curve, meaning marginal cost can shift within this gap without changing the profit-maximizing price, explaining observed price rigidity (price stickiness) in oligopolistic markets.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  17. 17.

    Two oligopolists, Firm X and Firm Y, must each simultaneously decide whether to 'Advertise' or 'Not Advertise'. The payoff matrix below shows (Firm X profit, Firm Y profit) in millions of dollars for each combination of strategies: {Both Advertise: (20, 20); X Advertises, Y Does Not: (40, 10); X Does Not, Y Advertises: (10, 40); Neither Advertises: (30, 30)}. (a) Identify Firm X's dominant strategy, if one exists. (b) Identify the Nash equilibrium of this game. (c) Explain why the Nash equilibrium outcome may not be the best outcome for both firms jointly.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. If Y advertises, X prefers advertising: $20m exceeds $10m. If Y does not, X still prefers advertising: $40m exceeds $30m. Advertising is X's dominant strategy and, by symmetry, Y's too.
    2. Both advertise is therefore Nash equilibrium at ($20m,$20m): either unilateral switch lowers the switcher's profit. Neither advertising gives ($30m,$30m), a larger joint $60m rather than $40m, but each would then gain by deviating to $40m.

    Common mistake: Calling the highest joint payoff Nash equilibrium without checking each firm's unilateral incentive.

    Marking points

    • Checks Firm X's best response to each of Y's choices: if Y advertises, X earns more by advertising (20 > 10); if Y does not advertise, X still earns more by advertising (40 > 30).
    • Identifies 'Advertise' as Firm X's dominant strategy, since it is the best choice regardless of what Firm Y does (and by symmetry, the same applies to Firm Y).
    • Identifies the Nash equilibrium as (Advertise, Advertise), with payoffs (20, 20), since neither firm can improve its own payoff by unilaterally changing its strategy.
    • Explains that if both firms instead cooperated and chose 'Not Advertise', both would earn a higher payoff (30, 30), but this outcome is unstable because each firm has an individual incentive to deviate and advertise, undercutting the other.

    Examiner tip: This payoff structure is a classic prisoner's dilemma: the individually rational dominant strategy for each player leads to a jointly worse outcome than mutual cooperation would achieve.

  18. 18.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Two oligopolists, Firm X and Firm Y, must each simultaneously decide whether to 'Advertise' or 'Not Advertise'. The payoff matrix below shows (Firm X profit, Firm Y profit) in millions of dollars for each combination of strategies: {Both Advertise: (20, 20); X Advertises, Y Does Not: (40, 10); X Does Not, Y Advertises: (10, 40); Neither Advertises: (30, 30)}. (a) Identify Firm X's dominant strategy, if one exists. (b) Identify the Nash equilibrium of this game. (c) Explain why the Nash equilibrium outcome may not be the best outcome for both firms jointly.” Their response addresses only this point: “Checks Firm X's best response to each of Y's choices: if Y advertises, X earns more by advertising (20 > 10); if Y does not advertise, X still earns more by advertising (40 > 30).” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Checks Firm X's best response to each of Y's choices: if Y advertises, X earns more by advertising (20 > 10); if Y does not advertise, X still earns more by advertising (40 > 30).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Identifies 'Advertise' as Firm X's dominant strategy, since it is the best choice regardless of what Firm Y does (and by symmetry, the same applies to Firm Y).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Identifies the Nash equilibrium as (Advertise, Advertise), with payoffs (20, 20), since neither firm can improve its own payoff by unilaterally changing its strategy.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that if both firms instead cooperated and chose 'Not Advertise', both would earn a higher payoff (30, 30), but this outcome is unstable because each firm has an individual incentive to deviate and advertise, undercutting the other.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  19. 19.

    Explain why firms in a cartel (collusive oligopoly) each have an individual incentive to secretly break the agreement, even though the cartel as a whole is more profitable if all members cooperate.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. A cartel restricts combined output to sustain a high industry price. At that price, one member can earn extra margin by secretly selling beyond its quota while other firms keep restricting supply.
    2. If many members do this, market supply rises and the high price falls, eroding the group's gain. Thus monitoring and credible discipline matter: collective profitability does not remove each member's private incentive to defect.

    Common mistake: Explaining only why firms collude, never why an individual member would cheat.

    Marking points

    • States that a cartel typically restricts total output and agrees on a higher, monopoly-like price to maximize joint industry profit.
    • Explains that at this high agreed price, any single member could individually increase its own profit by secretly producing and selling more than its agreed quota, since the price is well above its own marginal cost.
    • Explains that if enough members cheat in this way, total output rises and the market price falls, eventually breaking down the cartel agreement entirely.
    • Concludes that this tension between collective and individual incentives makes cartels inherently unstable without an effective enforcement mechanism.

    Examiner tip: Explain the incentive to exceed an output quota at the agreed high price, then show how widespread cheating undermines the agreement. A named real-world example is not required by this question.

  20. 20.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why firms in a cartel (collusive oligopoly) each have an individual incentive to secretly break the agreement, even though the cartel as a whole is more profitable if all members cooperate.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that a cartel typically restricts total output and agrees on a higher, monopoly-like price to maximize joint industry profit.” Evaluate the response against the complete 4-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that a cartel typically restricts total output and agrees on a higher, monopoly-like price to maximize joint industry profit.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that at this high agreed price, any single member could individually increase its own profit by secretly producing and selling more than its agreed quota, since the price is well above its own marginal cost.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that if enough members cheat in this way, total output rises and the market price falls, eventually breaking down the cartel agreement entirely.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that this tension between collective and individual incentives makes cartels inherently unstable without an effective enforcement mechanism.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  21. 21.

    Explain why a natural monopoly arises in an industry with very high fixed costs and declining long-run average costs over a large range of output, using the example of water supply infrastructure.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. Water pipes require a large network outlay before much water can be sold. Increasing delivery through that network spreads fixed cost over more units, keeping average cost falling over relevant market demand.
    2. Two suppliers duplicating pipes may each serve fewer customers at higher average cost than one network. That cost advantage explains natural monopoly, but does not ensure low consumer prices: monopoly power and regulation remain separate questions.

    Common mistake: Defining natural monopoly as ownership of a natural resource rather than the market-wide cost structure.

    Marking points

    • States that building the water pipe network involves an extremely large fixed cost, which is spread over more and more units of water supplied as output increases.
    • Explains that this causes long-run average cost to fall continuously (economies of scale) over a very large range of output, often large enough to cover the entire market demand.
    • Concludes that a single large firm can therefore supply the entire market at a lower average cost than two or more smaller firms each duplicating the fixed infrastructure, making a single-firm (monopoly) market structure the most cost-efficient outcome.

    Examiner tip: Natural monopoly concerns the cost advantage of serving market demand through one supplier. Cost efficiency does not itself guarantee fair prices or good service, so regulation or competitive procurement may still be relevant.

  22. 22.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why a natural monopoly arises in an industry with very high fixed costs and declining long-run average costs over a large range of output, using the example of water supply infrastructure.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that building the water pipe network involves an extremely large fixed cost, which is spread over more and more units of water supplied as output increases.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that building the water pipe network involves an extremely large fixed cost, which is spread over more and more units of water supplied as output increases.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that this causes long-run average cost to fall continuously (economies of scale) over a very large range of output, often large enough to cover the entire market demand.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that a single large firm can therefore supply the entire market at a lower average cost than two or more smaller firms each duplicating the fixed infrastructure, making a single-firm (monopoly) market structure the most cost-efficient outcome.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  23. 23.

    A monopoly faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and constant marginal cost MC = 20. Explain what price and quantity a regulator would set under a 'marginal cost pricing' rule, and state one problem this rule can cause for a natural monopoly with high fixed costs.

    [3 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. Marginal-cost pricing sets P = $20, so demand gives 100 - 2Q = 20 and Q = 40.
    2. For this constant-MC benchmark, revenue at that price covers variable cost only. Adding high network fixed costs makes AC exceed $20 and creates a loss; a subsidy or a carefully designed cost-recovery arrangement would be needed to maintain supply.

    Common mistake: Assuming allocatively efficient pricing must also cover a natural monopoly's total costs.

    Marking points

    • States that marginal cost pricing sets price equal to marginal cost: 100 − 2Q = 20.
    • Solves to obtain Q = 40 and P = $20, the allocatively efficient outcome.
    • States the problem: if the firm has substantial fixed costs, setting price equal to marginal cost (which does not include any contribution to fixed costs) will cause the firm to make a loss, since average cost exceeds price at this output.

    Examiner tip: This is exactly why regulators sometimes use 'average cost pricing' instead, setting price equal to average cost (P = AC) — this sacrifices some allocative efficiency but ensures the firm can at least break even without a government subsidy.

  24. 24.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “A monopoly faces demand P = 100 − 2Q and constant marginal cost MC = 20. Explain what price and quantity a regulator would set under a 'marginal cost pricing' rule, and state one problem this rule can cause for a natural monopoly with high fixed costs.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that marginal cost pricing sets price equal to marginal cost: 100 − 2Q = 20.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that marginal cost pricing sets price equal to marginal cost: 100 − 2Q = 20.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Solves to obtain Q = 40 and P = $20, the allocatively efficient outcome.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States the problem: if the firm has substantial fixed costs, setting price equal to marginal cost (which does not include any contribution to fixed costs) will cause the firm to make a loss, since average cost exceeds price at this output.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  25. 25.

    Explain the concept of a 'contestable market', and state why a market with high barriers to entry and exit cannot be contestable, even if it currently has only one firm operating in it.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Optional enrichment

    Syllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, first assessment 2022, updated October 2022; 2.11, pp.31-33 (printed pages). Contestability's hit-and-run/exit-cost model exceeds the specified market-structure models.

    Worked explanation

    1. A contestable market allows credible rapid entry and low-loss exit, so a potential rival can challenge an incumbent's high price even if it is currently the only firm.
    2. Large unrecoverable start-up costs or exclusive input access destroy that threat: entrants cannot enter cheaply or recover investment on exit. A single firm is therefore neither proof of weak competition nor proof of contestability; the entry and exit conditions decide.

    Common mistake: Equating a high initial investment with a sunk cost automatically; recoverability matters for exit.

    Marking points

    • Defines a contestable market as one with very low barriers to entry and exit, such that potential competitors could enter quickly if they saw an opportunity for profit, and exit again without significant loss ('hit-and-run' competition).
    • Explains that the mere threat of potential entry can discipline even a single existing firm's behavior, forcing it to keep prices close to average cost to deter entry, even without any actual competitors currently present.
    • States that high barriers to entry and exit (such as large sunk costs) prevent potential competitors from entering quickly or leaving without loss, removing this competitive discipline and allowing the existing firm to behave more like an unconstrained monopolist.

    Examiner tip: Contestability theory shifts the focus from counting the number of firms currently in a market to assessing the ease of entry and exit — a market with one firm can still behave competitively if it is genuinely contestable.

  26. 26.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain the concept of a 'contestable market', and state why a market with high barriers to entry and exit cannot be contestable, even if it currently has only one firm operating in it.” Their response addresses only this point: “Defines a contestable market as one with very low barriers to entry and exit, such that potential competitors could enter quickly if they saw an opportunity for profit, and exit again without significant loss ('hit-and-run' competition).” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Defines a contestable market as one with very low barriers to entry and exit, such that potential competitors could enter quickly if they saw an opportunity for profit, and exit again without significant loss ('hit-and-run' competition).
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that the mere threat of potential entry can discipline even a single existing firm's behavior, forcing it to keep prices close to average cost to deter entry, even without any actual competitors currently present.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that high barriers to entry and exit (such as large sunk costs) prevent potential competitors from entering quickly or leaving without loss, removing this competitive discipline and allowing the existing firm to behave more like an unconstrained monopolist.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  27. 27.

    In an industry with five firms, market shares are 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%, and 10%. Calculate the four-firm concentration ratio for this industry, and state what this value suggests about the level of competition in the industry.

    [3 marks]

    Worked explanation

    1. The four largest shares are 30%, 25%, 20% and 15%, so CR4 = 90%. The fifth firm's 10% is excluded.
    2. Four firms control almost all sales, consistent with a concentrated oligopoly. This ratio alone does not prove collusion or show the strength of import competition and potential entry; the relevant market definition matters.

    Common mistake: Adding all five shares to 100%, which gives no four-firm concentration measure.

    Marking points

    • Identifies the four largest firms' market shares: 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%.
    • Sums these shares: 30 + 25 + 20 + 15 = 90%.
    • States that a concentration ratio this high (90%) suggests the industry is highly concentrated, consistent with an oligopoly, since a small number of firms control nearly the entire market.

    Examiner tip: The n-firm concentration ratio always sums the market shares of the largest n firms — a value close to 100% indicates high concentration (oligopoly or monopoly), while a low value indicates a more fragmented, competitive market.

  28. 28.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “In an industry with five firms, market shares are 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%, and 10%. Calculate the four-firm concentration ratio for this industry, and state what this value suggests about the level of competition in the industry.” Their response addresses only this point: “Identifies the four largest firms' market shares: 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks]

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: Identifies the four largest firms' market shares: 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Sums these shares: 30 + 25 + 20 + 15 = 90%.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: States that a concentration ratio this high (90%) suggests the industry is highly concentrated, consistent with an oligopoly, since a small number of firms control nearly the entire market.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  29. 29.

    Explain the 'price leadership' model of oligopoly behavior, in which one dominant firm sets the price and other firms follow.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. In price leadership, one influential firm announces a price and rivals choose to follow rather than trigger a costly price war. This can coordinate prices through observation without an explicit agreement.
    2. A follower may see little gain from undercutting if the leader can retaliate with a sustainable lower price. Parallel pricing alone does not demonstrate that every oligopoly colludes, and firms can still compete on quality or service.

    Common mistake: Treating every identical price as evidence of a formal cartel rather than distinguishing observed matching from an agreement.

    Marking points

    • States that one large, typically lowest-cost firm in the industry (the price leader) sets its profit-maximizing price.
    • Explains that smaller rival firms, recognizing that competing on price against the dominant firm would be unprofitable or risky, choose to match (follow) the leader's price rather than compete directly.
    • Explains that this behavior allows the industry to reach a stable, coordinated price without any explicit collusive agreement, which can make it harder for competition authorities to prove anti-competitive behavior.

    Examiner tip: Price leadership can coordinate rivals' pricing without a formal written cartel agreement. Independent parallel pricing alone does not prove collusion. Whether particular conduct is unlawful depends on evidence of coordination and the applicable competition rules; absence of a formal agreement does not by itself prevent legal challenge.

  30. 30.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain the 'price leadership' model of oligopoly behavior, in which one dominant firm sets the price and other firms follow.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that one large, typically lowest-cost firm in the industry (the price leader) sets its profit-maximizing price.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that one large, typically lowest-cost firm in the industry (the price leader) sets its profit-maximizing price.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that smaller rival firms, recognizing that competing on price against the dominant firm would be unprofitable or risky, choose to match (follow) the leader's price rather than compete directly.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that this behavior allows the industry to reach a stable, coordinated price without any explicit collusive agreement, which can make it harder for competition authorities to prove anti-competitive behavior.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.

  31. 31.

    Explain why high barriers to entry, such as very large start-up capital requirements or exclusive access to a key resource, allow a monopoly to persist in earning supernormal profit in the long run, unlike firms in perfect competition.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Worked explanation

    1. In free-entry competition, visible supernormal profit attracts new supply and drives returns toward normal profit. A patent, exclusive input or prohibitive unrecoverable start-up requirement can block that adjustment.
    2. The incumbent can then retain profit above opportunity cost in the long run, provided demand and costs support it. Barriers permit sustained profit; they do not guarantee it if demand collapses or technology creates substitutes.

    Common mistake: Turning 'can sustain supernormal profit' into a guarantee that a monopoly always earns it.

    Marking points

    • States that supernormal profit in a competitive market normally attracts new entrants, which increases supply and competes the profit away over time.
    • Explains that high barriers to entry (such as prohibitive start-up costs, patents, or exclusive control of a key input) prevent potential competitors from entering, even when they observe the monopolist earning high profits.
    • Concludes that without this competitive pressure, the monopolist can continue earning supernormal profit indefinitely, in contrast to the perfectly competitive firm whose profit is eroded by free entry.

    Examiner tip: Barriers to entry are the single most important structural difference between monopoly and perfect competition — every other difference in pricing and profit outcomes ultimately traces back to whether entry is free or blocked.

  32. 32.

    Marking analysis: A learner attempts the following task: “Explain why high barriers to entry, such as very large start-up capital requirements or exclusive access to a key resource, allow a monopoly to persist in earning supernormal profit in the long run, unlike firms in perfect competition.” Their response addresses only this point: “States that supernormal profit in a competitive market normally attracts new entrants, which increases supply and competes the profit away over time.” Evaluate the response against the complete 3-mark task. Identify what earns credit and state every additional requirement needed for full marks.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Marking points

    • Recognises credit for the stated point: States that supernormal profit in a competitive market normally attracts new entrants, which increases supply and competes the profit away over time.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Explains that high barriers to entry (such as prohibitive start-up costs, patents, or exclusive control of a key input) prevent potential competitors from entering, even when they observe the monopolist earning high profits.
    • Checks this criterion, crediting equivalent work already shown or identifying what is missing: Concludes that without this competitive pressure, the monopolist can continue earning supernormal profit indefinitely, in contrast to the perfectly competitive firm whose profit is eroded by free entry.

    Examiner tip: Check each criterion, including equivalent work already shown. Do not demand an extra step merely to rewrite an equivalent answer. Do not award the same idea twice or infer work the learner did not show.