Economics SL
Commentary Selection and Policy Reasoning
- 1.
Preparation only. On 19 October 2026 a learner plans a commentary. Hypothetical candidate A is a newspaper report published 1 September 2026 about a new city congestion charge; B is a textbook chapter from 2023; C is a radio broadcast from 1 October 2026 without a published news article. Select the strongest candidate, justify two selection reasons, and state one portfolio check still needed. Do not write or submit a commentary.
[4 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- A provides an identifiable current intervention; its timing fits the stated writing date. B is a teaching source and C is only a broadcast.
- Before reserving A, compare it with the other planned commentaries for different units and sources and plan a distinct key concept. Suitability also depends on enough detail for independent analysis.
Common mistake: A suitable article is a starting point, not a completed commentary or portfolio.
Marking points
- Selects A, a recent published news report with a specific intervention to analyse.
- Explains that its publication is within one year of the proposed writing date.
- Explains that the textbook or broadcast alone is not an appropriate published news article for this task.
- Checks that the unit, source and key concept choices fit the remaining portfolio requirements, rather than assuming one article completes them.
Examiner tip: A suitable article is a starting point, not a completed commentary or portfolio.
- 2.
Preparation only. A hypothetical news scenario describes a city imposing a $2 per-journey tax on private taxi rides; ride supply is upward sloping and demand downward sloping. Plan an annotated competitive-market tax diagram and explain the incidence. Do not claim that these invented details are a published article.
[4 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- Identify the buyer price on demand and the net seller receipt on original supply at the post-tax quantity; the vertical difference must be $2.
- With ordinary upward supply and downward demand both sides bear part of the tax. Without elasticity data, no precise monetary split can be assigned. This diagram plan is practice for later application to a learner-selected article.
Common mistake: A $2 tax wedge does not imply that buyers alone pay $2 more; separate remittance from economic incidence.
Marking points
- Labels price per ride and rides per period, original demand and supply, and the original equilibrium.
- Shifts supply vertically up by $2 or uses an equivalent $2 tax wedge at the new quantity.
- Shows a higher buyer price, lower net seller price and reduced quantity under the stated slopes.
- Explains that relative demand and supply elasticities determine the burden split, not simply who remits the tax.
Examiner tip: A $2 tax wedge does not imply that buyers alone pay $2 more; separate remittance from economic incidence.
- 3.
Preparation only. In a hypothetical town, a public bus subsidy is proposed where buses run below capacity, but evening routes are infrequent. Develop one benefit for low-income workers, one limitation, and a conditional judgement using equity as the conceptual lens. State one piece of evidence needed from a real article before using this argument.
[4 marks] · no calculatorWorked explanation
- Trace the mechanism from lower operator cost through fares to access, making the pass-through assumption explicit.
- Contrast affordability with availability. A fare policy alone may miss the intended group if buses do not run when needed; use article-specific evidence to assess that constraint in any later authentic commentary.
Common mistake: Do not claim equity has improved for all workers merely because a subsidy is announced.
Marking points
- Explains that a passed-through subsidy can reduce fares and improve low-income workers' access to employment.
- Explains that poor evening frequency may still prevent shift workers using the service.
- Judges the subsidy more equitable if affordable fares are accompanied by usable services, acknowledging public-funding opportunity cost.
- Requests evidence such as actual pass-through, workers' journey times or evening ridership rather than inventing it.
Examiner tip: Do not claim equity has improved for all workers merely because a subsidy is announced.
- 4.
Preparation only; this is a fictional scenario, not a published article or a completed IA. A city imposes an enforced maximum monthly rent below the initial competitive equilibrium. Rental supply slopes upward and demand downward; assume no extra public housing, no subsidy and no illegal overcharging. Plan a labelled rent-control diagram, explain the resulting shortage, and evaluate through an equity lens whether all low-income applicants must benefit. Identify one allocation detail to check in an independently selected real news article; do not calculate welfare areas or write a commentary.
[5 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, published February 2020, updated October 2022, edition linked by 2026 examiner instructions; 2.7, printed pp.29-30: price ceilings and stakeholder consequences; Internal assessment, pp.67-72: application, key concepts and evaluation.. SL preparation applies the shared qualitative price-control diagram to equity; it deliberately excludes HL-only numerical market/welfare calculations. The existing topic remains preparation-only: invented stimulus cannot substitute for a learner-selected published news article or demonstrate completion of an assessed portfolio.
Worked explanation
- Draw the ceiling below equilibrium and read quantity supplied and demanded separately at that same rent. The policy fixes a legal maximum price, not a quantity at which both sides agree.
- Trace access after the shortage arises. Some allocation mechanism must select tenants; under equity, distinguish gains to those housed from those left searching and request actual rationing evidence before applying the argument to a real article.
Common mistake: A price ceiling does not create a new market-clearing equilibrium at the capped rent or guarantee housing for every applicant.
Marking points
- Labels monthly rent and rental units per period, demand, supply, the original equilibrium and a maximum rent below equilibrium.
- Shows quantity demanded exceeding quantity supplied at the ceiling, with the horizontal gap labelled shortage.
- Explains that a lower regulated rent increases desired rentals and reduces units offered along the unchanged curves.
- Judges that successful tenants may gain affordability but unsuccessful applicants may remain excluded; lower legal rent alone does not ensure equitable access for all.
- Requests an allocation detail such as waiting-list priorities or eligibility rules to determine whether scarce units reach low-income applicants.
Examiner tip: A price ceiling does not create a new market-clearing equilibrium at the capped rent or guarantee housing for every applicant.
- 5.
Preparation only. A fictional news-style summary claims 'Everyone is better off because GDP rose by 5%'. Nominal GDP increases from $200 billion in year 1 to $210 billion in year 2; the GDP deflator, with year 1 = 100, rises from 100 to 105. Population rises from 10.0 million to 10.2 million. Calculate year-2 real GDP in year-1 prices and the percentage change in real GDP per person, then explain two weaknesses in the claim using change as a conceptual lens. These invented figures are not authentic news evidence; do not write or submit a commentary.
[4 marks]Syllabus placement evidence: IB Economics guide, published February 2020, updated October 2022, edition linked by 2026 examiner instructions; 3.1, printed pp.35-36: real GDP, real GDP per capita and national-income statistics as wellbeing measures; Internal assessment, pp.67-72.. Uses shared SL calculations and measurement limitations as an application exercise for commentary preparation, not an HL-only technique. The change lens organises interpretation but does not make fictional figures a published extract; topic kind and independent-student IA requirements remain unchanged.
Worked explanation
- Remove price change before comparing output: 210/1.05 = 200 billion. Divide each real GDP total by its own year's population, keeping billions and millions consistent, to get $20000 and $19607.84 per person.
- Compute (19607.8431/20000 - 1) x 100 = -1.9608%. Under change, distinguish nominal totals, real totals and per-person change, then separate all three from a universal wellbeing conclusion; a later genuine commentary needs real article evidence about the claimed outcome.
Common mistake: Do not treat a nominal GDP increase as real growth, or infer every household's wellbeing from an average GDP figure.
Marking points
- Calculates year-2 real GDP = $210 billion x 100/105 = $200 billion in year-1 prices.
- Calculates real GDP per person falling from $20000 to approximately $19607.84, a fall of approximately 1.96%.
- Explains that the nominal 5% rise is offset by the price-level rise, so it does not demonstrate increased real aggregate output.
- Explains that an average output measure cannot establish everyone's wellbeing, since distribution or unmeasured wellbeing factors can differ; population growth further lowers average real output here.
Examiner tip: Do not treat a nominal GDP increase as real growth, or infer every household's wellbeing from an average GDP figure.
- 6.
Commentary preparation only. In a fictional coastal fishery it is impractical to exclude boats from the fishing ground, but every fish caught leaves fewer fish available for other boats and for breeding. No boat owns the remaining stock. Explain why the fish stock is a common-access resource rather than a pure public good. Explain the incentive that can produce excessive harvesting, and evaluate one condition needed for a catch limit to protect the stock. Identify evidence to seek in a future independently selected news article, using sustainability as the lens. No actual fishery data or published article is supplied; do not write an assessed commentary.
[5 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: IB Economics SL subject brief, first assessments 2022, copyright 2025: curriculum overview, 2.8 Market failure - externalities and common pool or common access resources; 2.9 Market failure - public goods.. Uses the explicitly named shared SL resource/public-good areas and sustainability in the existing commentary-preparation topic. This is qualitative application, not HL numerical welfare analysis. The brief establishes area placement, not statement-level certification; session guide verification and a genuine independently selected article remain necessary.
Worked explanation
- Classify the fish, not the water or the coast's scenic view. Open access does not imply non-rivalry: a removed fish cannot be caught again by another boat.
- Private revenue rewards harvesting now, while part of the stock cost falls on other users. A sustainable catch rule needs ecological information and credible compliance. Sustainability is a question about future resource availability, not a conclusion proved by announcing a limit.
Common mistake: Non-excludability alone does not make a resource a pure public good.
Marking points
- Identifies difficulty of excluding boats as non-excludability in the stated setting.
- Identifies rivalry: one boat's catch removes fish available to others, so the stock lacks the non-rivalry required of a pure public good.
- Explains that a boat captures its catch revenue but does not bear all losses it imposes on others or future users by depleting the shared stock, encouraging excessive harvesting.
- Evaluates one relevant condition with a reason: accepts either credible monitoring/enforcement because non-compliance can leave actual catches above the limit, or an ecologically appropriate total cap because catches exceeding regeneration can still deplete the stock even with full compliance. One evaluated condition is sufficient; both are not required.
- Requests relevant evidence such as stock estimates, regeneration, recorded catches or enforcement capacity before judging whether future access is protected.
Examiner tip: Non-excludability alone does not make a resource a pure public good.