IB · ENG A LANG LIT HL

English A: Language & Literature HL

PREPARATION: Individual oral and follow-up reasoning

Name: ____________________Date: November 19, 2026
  1. 1.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Written individual-oral PREPARATION using original hypothetical material, not eligible studied selections. A fictional dramatic fragment places a tenant behind a glass screen while an official says 'We hear every voice'; a fictional public-information panel shows identical speech bubbles above a queue under the same words. Define a focused global issue, evaluate how one formal choice in each selection could complicate the promise of participation, and specify the different wider-work/body-of-work evidence needed to avoid an unsupported claim that both creators intend the same criticism. No oral is performed.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Syllabus placement evidence: Language A examiner instructions (2021), Individual Oral: The task; Applying the assessment criteria. Shared SL/HL oral requirement, using a distinct advanced rehearsal of counter-readings, analytical development or evidential reliability; no additional official HL oral criterion or real performance is claimed.

    Worked explanation

    1. Institutional control over whose contributions influence decisions is more focused than the broad theme 'power': it can affect local housing encounters across different societies. The tenant's physical separation makes the official's assertion open to questioning.
    2. The screen may stage a barrier despite the dialogue's inclusive promise. Identical speech bubbles could suggest standardised expression or simply equal access; the panel's visual repetition does not by itself establish satire.
    3. Test the play's wider treatment of the tenant's agency separately from the panel series' authorship, audience and surrounding messaging. An oral plan needs supported extract-to-whole links for each selection, not an assumed common critical intention.

    Common mistake: Assuming every slogan/image tension proves deliberate satire collapses two distinct contexts into an unsupported claim about creator intention.

    Marking points

    • Defines a specific issue such as institutional filtering of public participation and justifies its transnational and everyday relevance.
    • Analyses dramatic staging and the panel's repeated visual form as different possible tensions between speaking and being heard.
    • Requests relevant dramatic development and authenticated campaign/context evidence, recognising that irony or critical authorial intention is not established equally in both.

    Examiner tip: Assuming every slogan/image tension proves deliberate satire collapses two distinct contexts into an unsupported claim about creator intention.

  2. 2.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Written oral-argument PREPARATION. In an original hypothetical literary fragment a school gate is described as 'a mouth that swallowed our names'; a hypothetical non-literary enrolment notice states 'Applicants must be processed in order of number.' A rehearsal outline contains six examples of dehumanisation but no explanation of how they work. Replace the list with two different analytical claim-evidence-effect chains, identify one non-dehumanising counter-reading of the notice, and explain how that counter-reading should qualify the global-issue argument. These fragments are not studied works and no live delivery is supplied.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Syllabus placement evidence: Language A examiner instructions (2021), Individual Oral: The task; Applying the assessment criteria. Shared SL/HL oral requirement, using a distinct advanced rehearsal of counter-readings, analytical development or evidential reliability; no additional official HL oral criterion or real performance is claimed.

    Worked explanation

    1. For the literary chain, the gate becomes a consuming 'mouth', while 'names' stand for personal identity: the institution is represented as actively absorbing individuality. This explains the effect of a choice rather than merely naming personification.
    2. For the notice, 'must' imposes an obligation and 'processed' treats applications administratively; numerical ordering can reduce attention to personal circumstances. The notice's functional genre differs from the fragment's figurative perspective.
    3. Number order can also protect applicants against favouritism. A qualified oral claim should examine when necessary procedure constrains individual recognition, checking the wider notice and literary work before interpreting administration itself as inherently hostile.

    Common mistake: Counting more examples cannot replace explaining form and effect, and a fair queuing rule is not automatically evidence of deliberate dehumanisation.

    Marking points

    • Builds a literary chain linking the gate/mouth personification and swallowed names to institutional erasure of individual identity.
    • Builds a distinct non-literary chain linking passive obligation, processing vocabulary and numbered order to depersonalisation or procedural standardisation.
    • Offers and weighs a plausible fairness/efficient-queue counter-reading, narrowing the argument rather than asserting all administrative ordering is oppressive.

    Examiner tip: Counting more examples cannot replace explaining form and effect, and a fair queuing rule is not automatically evidence of deliberate dehumanisation.

  3. 3.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Written follow-up PREPARATION, not live questioning. Original hypothetical oral evidence: one extract shows a narrator omitting a neighbour's account; another passage from the same invented text says 'I copied her words exactly', but supplies no independent corroboration. A teacher asks, 'Does the second passage disprove your claim that this narrator controls whose voice reaches us?' Draft a qualified answer using both details, distinguish narrator self-report from independent verification, and identify a wider-work check that could change your conclusion. No complete or published work is supplied.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Syllabus placement evidence: Language A examiner instructions (2021), Individual Oral: The task; Applying the assessment criteria. Shared SL/HL oral requirement, using a distinct advanced rehearsal of counter-readings, analytical development or evidential reliability; no additional official HL oral criterion or real performance is claimed.

    Worked explanation

    1. A defensible reply is: 'It challenges the claim that the narrator always suppresses others, but not necessarily the claim that the narrator selects their access to the reader. Omitting one account and claiming fidelity to another can coexist.'
    2. 'I copied' is itself spoken by the potentially selective narrator. Without the original account or another perspective, it is evidence of a claim to accuracy, not external confirmation that nothing was excluded.
    3. Check whether the wider text supplies the neighbour's independent voice or the source record. If it corroborates complete transmission, narrow the argument to selective omission in particular moments rather than universal falsification; written rehearsal does not demonstrate spontaneous response.

    Common mistake: Treating a narrator's promise of accuracy as external corroboration assumes the reliability that the question asks you to examine.

    Marking points

    • Uses omission and the claim of exact copying together to qualify rather than simply repeat or abandon the interpretation of narrative control.
    • Distinguishes the narrator's assertion of fidelity from independent evidence that the neighbour's words are fully represented.
    • Specifies a concrete wider-work check, such as another perspective or the presentation of the source document, and states how contrary evidence would alter the claim.

    Examiner tip: Treating a narrator's promise of accuracy as external corroboration assumes the reliability that the question asks you to examine.

  4. 4.

    PREPARATION ONLY, written oral reasoning. Original hypothetical provenance record: a fictional single-author housing cartoon was published in 2005; a housing policy was announced in 2015. The cartoon shows a ladder ending below a doorway while its caption promises equal opportunity. A draft says the cartoon directly attacks the 2015 announcement. Diagnose the chronological error, develop a supported analysis of the supplied image-caption relationship, and distinguish historical context you would need from a present-day application you may cautiously propose. The drawing and actual policy documents are not supplied, and neither is a studied literary work.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Syllabus placement evidence: Language A examiner instructions, first-assessment-2021 course: Individual Oral, The task; Criterion A (knowledge and interpretation); Criterion B (authorial choices). Practises context-sensitive oral interpretation for HL with shared SL/HL oral expectations, not an invented HL-only rule. Hypothetical provenance and written reasoning do not supply eligible selections or live assessment.

    Worked explanation

    1. 2005 precedes 2015 by ten years, so this record does not support a response to that later announcement. A claim about revision would require evidence, not speculation used to rescue the draft.
    2. The described ladder suggests attempted upward movement but blocks arrival. Set that visual limitation against the caption's inclusive promise to analyse representation without asserting a specific historical target.
    3. Research the original venue, audience and contemporary debate; separately explain why the representation may illuminate a current access problem. Relevance now is not proof of intention then, and written analysis supplies no oral performance.

    Common mistake: A text's relevance to a later policy does not show that its creator was responding to an event that had not occurred.

    Marking points

    • Rejects a direct response to the 2015 announcement on the supplied 2005 publication chronology unless separate evidence of later revision/republication is established.
    • Explains how the ladder's failure to reach the door may undermine the caption's promise by representing access as incomplete.
    • Seeks contemporaneous publication/audience and housing context to justify historical interpretation rather than inventing the creator's target.
    • Distinguishes a qualified present-day application to unequal opportunity from a claim about original intention, retaining the need for wider-body and literary evidence in a real oral.

    Examiner tip: A text's relevance to a later policy does not show that its creator was responding to an event that had not occurred.

  5. 5.

    PREPARATION ONLY in writing. Original hypothetical poster description: a large photograph of a factory owner occupies the upper two-thirds; a narrow lower strip shows six workers, each too small for facial details to be visible; the headline 'Built by us' spans both zones. For the focused issue of unequal public recognition of labour, an oral note reads, 'Big picture, small pictures, pronoun, inequality.' Turn this into two connected analytical sentences explaining scale, placement and the ambiguous collective pronoun. Then identify one feature of the complete design and one wider-body check needed to decide whether the poster celebrates collective labour or privileges ownership. No actual poster, studied corpus, literary work or spoken delivery is supplied.

    [4 marks] · no calculator

    Syllabus placement evidence: Language A examiner instructions, first-assessment-2021 course: Individual Oral, The task; Criteria B and D. Rehearses analytical expression of visual relationships for an HL oral plan under shared oral criteria. Description-based sentences are preparation, not demonstrated spoken language or completed body-of-work analysis.

    Worked explanation

    1. Translate labels into relations: 'The owner's enlarged upper portrait grants an individually recognisable figure greater visual prominence, while the lower strip renders the workers a less individuated group.' This links scale and placement to a defensible possible effect.
    2. Continue: 'Although the headline verbally includes the workers, its shared pronoun may either counterbalance the visual hierarchy or conceal how unevenly credit is distributed.' This keeps the relationship open to evaluation rather than assuming hypocrisy.
    3. Check whether names/captions redistribute recognition in the complete design, then inspect how the same creator represents workers elsewhere. A set of written sentences cannot establish spoken clarity, pronunciation or responsive delivery.

    Common mistake: Naming size, position and a pronoun without explaining their interaction leaves the oral at feature spotting.

    Marking points

    • Explains how the owner's greater scale and upper placement may confer salience or hierarchy relative to the workers' small lower images.
    • Explains that 'us' appears inclusive but may either bridge or mask the unequal visual distribution of recognition.
    • Connects the two observations in analytical sentences rather than listing devices or claiming actual audience reactions.
    • Requests a relevant full-design feature such as caption/name attribution and a distinct wider-series comparison that could discriminate between the two readings.

    Examiner tip: Naming size, position and a pronoun without explaining their interaction leaves the oral at feature spotting.