Psychology HL
Abnormal psychology (2026 legacy option)
- 1.
A hypothetical classification exercise gives two assessors the same anonymised descriptions. They agree on every label, but the descriptions omit duration, impairment and cultural context. Distinguish diagnostic reliability from validity and explain why agreement alone is insufficient. Do not diagnose anyone.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.1 Abnormal psychology (pp.35-36), factors influencing diagnosis / etiology / treatment. Legacy option selected at HL, not the 2027 context label; diagnosis exercises are conceptual and not clinical judgement.
Worked explanation
- Agreement suggests inter-rater reliability for these descriptions. It does not show that the categories or their application capture the relevant condition.
- Missing duration, functional impact and context may undermine interpretation even if every assessor makes the same decision.
Common mistake: Calling unanimous agreement proof of diagnostic truth mistakes consistency for validity.
Marking points
- Defines reliability as consistency across assessments.
- Defines validity as whether the classification accurately represents the intended condition.
- Explains that consistent use of incomplete criteria can produce agreement without valid diagnosis.
Examiner tip: Calling unanimous agreement proof of diagnostic truth mistakes consistency for validity.
- 2.
Hypothetical survey reports that 18 of 120 respondents in community A and 12 of 120 in community B cross the same screening threshold for low mood. Calculate both rates and explain two reasons they do not establish a biological difference in depressive disorders.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.1 Abnormal psychology (pp.35-36), factors influencing diagnosis / etiology / treatment. Legacy option selected at HL, not the 2027 context label; diagnosis exercises are conceptual and not clinical judgement.
Worked explanation
- 18/120 = 0.15 and 12/120 = 0.10, so the observed gap is 5 percentage points in this hypothetical sample.
- Different interpretations of items or willingness to report symptoms may contribute. A survey neither diagnoses disorders nor separates biological explanations from social conditions and sampling.
Common mistake: Calling screening-positive respondents diagnosed cases overstates what the measure establishes.
Marking points
- Calculates screening-positive rates of 15% and 10%.
- Distinguishes screening thresholds from a clinical diagnosis and considers cross-cultural measurement equivalence.
- Identifies sampling, reporting or contextual confounds rather than inferring biological causation.
Examiner tip: Calling screening-positive respondents diagnosed cases overstates what the measure establishes.
- 3.
Hypothetical non-clinical methods exercise: a treatment evaluation compares volunteers receiving an intervention with people on a waiting list; only completers' scores are reported. Explain one selection problem, one attrition problem and one design/reporting improvement. Do not recommend a treatment.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.1 Abnormal psychology (pp.35-36), factors influencing diagnosis / etiology / treatment. Legacy option selected at HL, not the 2027 context label; diagnosis exercises are conceptual and not clinical judgement.
Worked explanation
- An apparent treatment difference can reflect initial motivation or severity rather than the intervention. Reporting only completers may exclude people who benefited least.
- An ethically approved controlled design and explicit participant-flow reporting improve interpretation. Neither change permits a clinical recommendation from this invented example.
Common mistake: Ignoring withdrawals can exaggerate apparent effectiveness when attrition is related to outcome.
Marking points
- Recognises that allocation or volunteering can make groups differ before treatment.
- Recognises that non-completers may differ systematically from completers, biasing reported outcomes.
- Proposes ethical random allocation where appropriate plus transparent reporting/follow-up of withdrawals, or another justified correction.
Examiner tip: Ignoring withdrawals can exaggerate apparent effectiveness when attrition is related to outcome.
- 4.
Original hypothetical legacy abnormal-option theory exercise; do not diagnose anyone. A simplified vulnerability-stress model proposes that predisposition and stressful circumstances interact in the risk of depressive disorders. Explain why this differs from saying a predisposition inevitably produces a disorder, identify how two people with similar predisposition could have different outcomes, and state evidence needed before treating a measured predisposition as causal. No participant findings are supplied.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, June 2023 edition, 2.4.1 Abnormal psychology: Etiology - Explanations for disorders; integration of approaches and research methods. Illustrates an interaction explanation for a permitted disorder category in a selected legacy HL option. Not a screening tool, diagnosis, fabricated study or requirement to study every option.
Worked explanation
- An interaction explanation allows the effect of vulnerability to depend on circumstances. Similar vulnerability need not imply the same exposure, support or eventual outcome, and no individual probability is supplied here.
- A prospective design could establish that the measured factor precedes outcomes and examine exposure, but alternative causes and whether the measure captures vulnerability still require evaluation. This model is not a method of diagnosing a person.
Common mistake: Reading a predisposition as a deterministic diagnosis or assuming stress alone explains every case.
Marking points
- Explains predisposition as vulnerability rather than a sufficient or inevitable cause.
- Links differing stress exposure or protective resources to different possible outcomes within an interaction account.
- Requires temporal evidence and consideration of common causes/measurement validity rather than causation from association alone.
Examiner tip: Reading a predisposition as a deterministic diagnosis or assuming stress alone explains every case.
- 5.
Original hypothetical legacy abnormal-option methods exercise. A fictional assessor tentatively considers an anxiety-disorder explanation for an anonymised account, then asks only questions likely to confirm that explanation and ignores information about temporary circumstances. Explain confirmation bias in this evidence search, propose a specific safeguard, and distinguish that safeguard from proof that any eventual classification is valid. Do not classify the person.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, June 2023 edition, 2.4.1 Abnormal psychology: Factors influencing diagnosis - The role of clinical biases. Adds evidence-search bias rather than duplicating assessor-agreement or screening-rate tasks. Selected legacy HL option practice only; no diagnosis is requested or supplied.
Worked explanation
- The problem is not merely having a tentative hypothesis: it is allowing that hypothesis to select which evidence counts. Temporary circumstances are potentially relevant counterevidence, not automatically irrelevant noise.
- A preplanned balanced question set and a reviewer examining alternative explanations can make the search less one-sided. The classification framework and adequacy of evidence still need separate evaluation; this miniature account cannot establish a diagnosis.
Common mistake: Assuming a checklist guarantees an unbiased and valid classification regardless of what it asks.
Marking points
- Identifies preferential seeking/weighting of confirming evidence after the initial hypothesis.
- Proposes systematically checking disconfirming information and plausible alternatives, for example with a balanced structured assessment and independent review.
- Explains that reducing search bias does not establish construct validity or replace necessary duration, impairment and contextual evidence.
Examiner tip: Assuming a checklist guarantees an unbiased and valid classification regardless of what it asks.