Psychology HL
Human relationships (2027 context)
- 1.
Hypothetical newcomer scenario: a student adopts a club's shorthand but keeps important home practices. Use acculturation to distinguish integration from assimilation, apply perspective to explain why the student's own account matters and avoid treating categories as inevitable outcomes.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide first assessment 2027, Syllabus content: Human relationships, Tables 4.8 and 4.9 (p.32). 2027 context includes group behaviour and interpersonal communication; HL enrolment does not make shared context content HL-only.
Worked explanation
- Keeping home practices while joining club communication is compatible with integration, but a short description cannot establish the student's full strategy.
- Ask how they understand belonging and which choices are voluntary. A model organises possibilities; it does not make categories permanent traits or value judgements.
Common mistake: Treating use of local slang as proof of total assimilation overgeneralises one behaviour.
Marking points
- Integration combines engagement with the receiving setting and maintenance of heritage practices.
- Assimilation involves adoption of the receiving culture with reduced heritage maintenance; shorthand alone is insufficient evidence.
- Seeks the student's interpretation and acknowledges context, agency and change rather than assigning a fixed label.
Examiner tip: Treating use of local slang as proof of total assimilation overgeneralises one behaviour.
- 2.
Hypothetical group: members privately dislike a proposal but publicly support it after the chair speaks. Explain normative versus informational conformity, propose one way to separate them and discuss why a public/private difference does not prove a single cause.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide first assessment 2027, Syllabus content: Human relationships, Tables 4.8 and 4.9 (p.32). 2027 context includes group behaviour and interpersonal communication; HL enrolment does not make shared context content HL-only.
Worked explanation
- Members may fear disagreeing with the chair, or may infer that the chair has better information. Both can produce public agreement.
- Compare anonymous/private judgements and vary evidence clarity in an ethical hypothetical design. Different responses support an inference but do not reveal motives with certainty.
Common mistake: Calling every agreement normative ignores genuine uncertainty and others' perceived expertise.
Marking points
- Normative conformity concerns acceptance or avoidance of rejection; informational concerns trusting others' judgement under uncertainty.
- An anonymous response condition or manipulation of task ambiguity can help distinguish mechanisms.
- Recognises that social pressure and perceived expertise can operate together and that anonymity may change more than one feature.
Examiner tip: Calling every agreement normative ignores genuine uncertainty and others' perceived expertise.
- 3.
Hypothetical disagreement: one group member replies only 'fine' in a message. Another concludes they are hostile. Use a cognitive explanation and the concept of bias to explain the inference, then draft a clarification that could improve communication without claiming to know the sender's intention.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide first assessment 2027, Syllabus content: Human relationships, Tables 4.8 and 4.9 (p.32). 2027 context includes group behaviour and interpersonal communication; HL enrolment does not make shared context content HL-only.
Worked explanation
- Prior conflict may prime a negative interpretation of an ambiguous word, so the recipient treats an inference as a fact. The sender may instead be busy or genuinely agree.
- A neutral clarification tests alternatives and invites information rather than escalating blame. It is a possible communication strategy, not a guaranteed relationship intervention.
Common mistake: Treating inferred hostility as an observed fact ignores ambiguity and alternative explanations.
Marking points
- Identifies an attribution/interpretation bias such as reading ambiguous brevity through a prior negative expectation.
- Explains that the message underdetermines motive because tone and context are missing.
- Offers a neutral clarification such as 'Does that plan work for you, or would you prefer a change?' rather than a hostile accusation.
Examiner tip: Treating inferred hostility as an observed fact ignores ambiguity and alternative explanations.
- 4.
Original hypothetical 2027 relationships exercise. A voluntary community club first asks adults to display a small recycling reminder and later asks them to help at a recycling event. Explain how a foot-in-the-door compliance account could predict increased agreement to the larger request, distinguish compliance from a demonstrated private attitude change, and specify a fair direct-request comparison. This is analysis of an invented scenario, not permission to pressure volunteers.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, first assessment 2027: Human relationships - Group behaviour, Table 4.8, Compliance techniques. Adds a specific compliance-technique application distinct from existing conformity and acculturation questions. Shared 2027 content on the HL track, not an HL-only requirement or an actual study.
Worked explanation
- The account predicts a difference between a small-then-large sequence and a direct large request, not that every person must comply. A desire to appear consistent is one possible mechanism.
- Someone may agree out of politeness without a durable attitude change. Compare the sequence with an equally voluntary direct request and measure the relevant outcome rather than inferring private beliefs from public agreement.
Common mistake: Calling compliance proof of internal acceptance or treating refusal as a failure that should be overcome.
Marking points
- Explains that agreeing to a small initial request may promote consistency/commitment when responding to a related larger request.
- Distinguishes agreement to an explicit request from evidence of privately endorsing the underlying attitude.
- Proposes comparable randomly allocated adults receiving only the same large request, with equal freedom to decline and no penalty.
Examiner tip: Calling compliance proof of internal acceptance or treating refusal as a failure that should be overcome.
- 5.
Original hypothetical 2027 relationships exercise. Two departments in a voluntary organisation describe each other as outsiders despite doing similar work. A facilitator proposes keeping department identities but highlighting a shared organisation identity in joint planning. Explain the social-identity mechanism, give an observable indicator that would test more inclusive behaviour rather than slogans alone, and explain why this plan need not erase subgroup identities or guarantee lasting cooperation.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, first assessment 2027: Human relationships - Group behaviour, Table 4.8, Social identity theory (explain and change group behaviours). Applies the change-behaviour objective to inclusive categorisation rather than the legacy label-preference question. Shared 2027 context delivered at HL; no intervention effectiveness or practical completion is claimed.
Worked explanation
- If both departments are seen as part of 'our organisation', the boundary defining insiders may become more inclusive. The proposal does not require abandoning every valued local affiliation.
- Observe appropriately consented cross-department choices or exchanges rather than counting repetition of an inclusive slogan. Existing inequalities and incentives could sustain separation even if the shared identity becomes more salient.
Common mistake: Assuming a shared label automatically removes discrimination or requires everyone to become identical.
Marking points
- Explains that a broader shared in-group may change categorisation and extend favourable treatment across department boundaries.
- Specifies a behavioural indicator such as voluntary cross-department information sharing on comparable tasks over time.
- Recognises that subgroup identity can persist and unresolved status, resources or prior conflict may limit durable effects.
Examiner tip: Assuming a shared label automatically removes discrimination or requires everyone to become identical.