Psychology HL
Human relationships (2026 legacy option)
- 1.
Hypothetical interaction: Amir says 'You never listen'; Jo replies 'You only want to win.' Explain how attribution and communication could sustain the conflict, then propose a specific rephrasing and explain its possible effect.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.4 Psychology of human relationships (pp.39-40), personal relationships / group dynamics / social responsibility. Legacy personal relationships, group dynamics and social responsibility option, not evidence of all 2027 requirements.
Worked explanation
- Both statements infer enduring negative motives rather than identifying a specific event. That invites defensive counterattack instead of clarification.
- A behaviour-focused statement names an observable difficulty and a request, making a cooperative response easier without guaranteeing that the relationship improves.
Common mistake: Promising one communication technique will repair every conflict ignores context and reciprocal responses.
Marking points
- Identifies stable negative attributions or overgeneralisation in the exchange.
- Explains how accusatory wording can elicit defensiveness and reciprocal blame.
- Offers a concrete behaviour-focused request such as 'When I was interrupted, I lost my point; may I finish?' with a mechanism for reducing escalation.
Examiner tip: Promising one communication technique will repair every conflict ignores context and reciprocal responses.
- 2.
Hypothetical team task: pupils compete for a prize against another group, then cooperate on a project neither group can finish alone. Explain a realistic-conflict account of the change, distinguish shared goals from mere contact, and identify a limit of this scenario.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.4 Psychology of human relationships (pp.39-40), personal relationships / group dynamics / social responsibility. Legacy personal relationships, group dynamics and social responsibility option, not evidence of all 2027 requirements.
Worked explanation
- Competition can make the other group an obstacle to a valued goal. A new goal requiring both groups can change incentives toward cooperation.
- Mere contact leaves competitive incentives intact. Actual effects depend on context and require evidence; this invented task illustrates the theory only.
Common mistake: Equating contact with cooperative interdependence overlooks the mechanism of the proposed explanation.
Marking points
- Links competition over a valued scarce reward to intergroup tension.
- Explains that interdependent superordinate goals require cooperation, unlike simply placing groups together.
- Recognises that the hypothetical description is not empirical evidence or a demonstration that all prejudice will disappear.
Examiner tip: Equating contact with cooperative interdependence overlooks the mechanism of the proposed explanation.
- 3.
Hypothetical helping scenario: a student drops papers in a busy corridor; several observers look to one another and no one moves. Explain diffusion of responsibility and pluralistic ignorance, then propose a change that targets one mechanism.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide (2017, June 2023 edition), 2.4.4 Psychology of human relationships (pp.39-40), personal relationships / group dynamics / social responsibility. Legacy personal relationships, group dynamics and social responsibility option, not evidence of all 2027 requirements.
Worked explanation
- Observers may expect someone else to act, while also reading the group's inaction as a sign that nothing needs doing.
- 'You in the green coat, could you help collect these?' assigns an identifiable role and targets diffusion. It does not guarantee helping or isolate all influences.
Common mistake: Treating both mechanisms as simple selfishness misses their different social-information processes.
Marking points
- Diffusion means each observer feels less personally responsible because others are present.
- Pluralistic ignorance means interpreting others' inaction as evidence that help is unnecessary.
- A specific individual request assigns responsibility, or a clear statement of need reduces ambiguity, with the target mechanism explained.
Examiner tip: Treating both mechanisms as simple selfishness misses their different social-information processes.
- 4.
Original hypothetical legacy relationships-option exercise. Two adults meeting weekly at a language club gradually exchange more personal but voluntary information and report greater closeness. Explain how reciprocal self-disclosure could contribute to relationship formation, identify a plausible reverse-direction explanation, and explain why cultural and privacy preferences limit a universal rule that more disclosure is always better.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, June 2023 edition, 2.4.4 Psychology of human relationships: Personal relationships - Formation of personal relationships; Role of communication. Targets relationship formation rather than the existing conflict-rephrasing task in a selected legacy HL option. Original illustration, not evidence of universal effects or an instruction to disclose.
Worked explanation
- Offering information and receiving a respectful response may increase trust, allowing a relationship to develop. But trust may already have grown through shared activity and made disclosure possible, so the direction cannot be read from co-occurrence.
- Unwanted disclosure or pressure to reciprocate may reduce comfort. Explain the mechanism conditionally and respect different boundaries instead of prescribing intimate disclosure as a universal strategy.
Common mistake: Treating voluntary disclosure as permission to pressure another person to reveal private information.
Marking points
- Links reciprocal disclosure and responsive listening to trust or perceived understanding.
- Explains that increasing closeness could enable disclosure rather than disclosure solely causing closeness.
- Explains that appropriateness, consent and cultural/personal boundaries affect the meaning and consequences of disclosure.
Examiner tip: Treating voluntary disclosure as permission to pressure another person to reveal private information.
- 5.
Original hypothetical legacy social-responsibility exercise. An adult anonymously spends time helping a stranger complete a harmless administrative form, with no audience or material reward. A commentator says anonymity proves the helper's motive is entirely altruistic. Explain an empathy-based altruistic account, give an egoistic alternative compatible with anonymity, and propose evidence that could help distinguish the accounts without claiming direct access to motives or withholding needed help.
[3 marks] · no calculatorCourse scope: Legacy course
Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology guide, June 2023 edition, 2.4.4 Psychology of human relationships: Social responsibility - By-standerism; Prosocial behaviour; research methods and ethics. Adds evaluation of motives for prosocial behaviour rather than repeating the existing bystander-mechanism task or base-bank group categorisation question. Selected legacy HL option only; original hypothetical helping account, not a real study or evidence of pure altruism.
Worked explanation
- An empathy-based interpretation centres on improving the stranger's situation. Anonymity removes one reputational opportunity but not private satisfaction or relief from discomfort, so it does not establish the motive by itself.
- Compare predictions in benign hypothetical choices where concern for the other and relief for oneself would lead to different actions, alongside voluntary accounts of reasons. Never create unmet needs to test helping; even converging indicators cannot directly reveal a pure motive.
Common mistake: Treating the absence of public reward as proof that helping has no possible self-benefit.
Marking points
- Explains helping motivated by concern for the stranger's welfare rather than a benefit to the helper.
- Explains that relief of the helper's own distress or private satisfaction remains possible even without an audience or payment.
- Proposes ethically obtained converging evidence, such as accounts of reasons and choices in harmless scenarios varying alternative relief opportunities, while acknowledging that motives may be mixed and self-reports fallible.
Examiner tip: Treating the absence of public reward as proof that helping has no possible self-benefit.