Psychology HL
PREPARATION: Research proposal IA (first assessment 2027)
- 1.
PREPARATION ONLY. 2027 research-proposal PREPARATION, not data collection. You want to understand how adult volunteers who recently joined a community walking group describe social support. Compare purposive sampling of contrasting attendance histories with recruiting only the group leader's friends. Define the population of interest, justify a semi-structured interview and its sampling choice, and explain the limits of causal and population claims. All recruitment is hypothetical.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2027, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Suitability of topics. The new shared IA is a justified proposal about a population of interest, not research conducted; these are selected planning components only. Distinct advanced HL-track rehearsal; IA and practical requirements remain shared with SL, not additional HL-only prescription.
Worked explanation
- A possible population is adults who joined the named community programme within the last three months. Different attendance histories may reveal experiences that a leader's friendship network systematically misses.
- Interviews can ask how participants describe support and probe contrasting accounts; purposive selection can seek regular and infrequent attenders without claiming random representativeness. Recruitment should be independent enough that criticism does not threaten a participant's relationship with the leader.
- These choices broaden perspectives but cannot isolate whether attendance caused well-being or estimate how common each account is across all newcomers. A complete proposal still needs verified published grounding and justified consent and data procedures.
Common mistake: Calling a deliberately varied purposive sample representative in a statistical sense confuses analytic breadth with probability sampling.
Marking points
- Defines a bounded adult population with a specified recent joining period and group setting.
- Justifies semi-structured interviews for participants' meanings and purposive variation in attendance rather than a friendship-only convenience sample.
- Recognises gatekeeper/social-desirability and selection risks and that purposive accounts cannot establish population prevalence or a causal health benefit.
Examiner tip: Calling a deliberately varied purposive sample representative in a statistical sense confuses analytic breadth with probability sampling.
- 2.
PREPARATION ONLY. 2027 proposal-measurement PREPARATION. A hypothetical survey of adult club members measures belonging only with 'People here agree with me', rated 1-5, then proposes comparing two language groups. Explain a construct-validity problem, write a better two-item measure with response anchors and a time frame, and propose a pre-use check for comparable interpretation across languages. No survey is administered.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2027, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Suitability of topics. The new shared IA is a justified proposal about a population of interest, not research conducted; these are selected planning components only. Distinct advanced HL-track rehearsal; IA and practical requirements remain shared with SL, not additional HL-only prescription.
Worked explanation
- A person can feel accepted while disagreeing, or agree while feeling excluded. The single item therefore underrepresents belonging and may measure perceived conformity instead.
- Possible items are 'During the last four weeks, how often did you feel included in club activities?' and 'During the last four weeks, how often did you feel accepted when you expressed a different view?' Both can use never / rarely / sometimes / often / always, with a not-applicable option for the second.
- Before proposed use, have suitable bilingual reviewers and hypothetical cognitive interviews examine what 'included', 'accepted' and the scale categories mean to each group. The check can identify problems, not prove full measurement equivalence or create actual participant data.
Common mistake: A literally accurate translation can still leave a construct or response category interpreted differently across groups.
Marking points
- Explains that agreement is not equivalent to belonging and may confound perceived inclusion with conformity or shared opinions.
- Proposes two distinct neutral items about inclusion/acceptance over a defined period with explicit response anchors, rather than merely rewording agreement.
- Plans cognitive interviewing/translation review in both language groups to test meaning and response-category interpretation, without assuming translation alone establishes equivalence.
Examiner tip: A literally accurate translation can still leave a construct or response category interpreted differently across groups.
- 3.
PREPARATION ONLY. 2027 qualitative-proposal PREPARATION. A hypothetical researcher, also a volunteer tutor, proposes interviewing adults about helpful study feedback. The draft would recruit only their own learners, code every mention of praise as 'effective feedback', and discard criticism as misunderstanding. Propose three justified changes addressing recruitment/power, interpretive reflexivity and disconfirming accounts. Keep the proposal hypothetical: do not invent findings or conduct interviews.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2027, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Suitability of topics. The new shared IA is a justified proposal about a population of interest, not research conducted; these are selected planning components only. Distinct advanced HL-track rehearsal; IA and practical requirements remain shared with SL, not additional HL-only prescription.
Worked explanation
- Learners may feel that refusal or criticism affects tutoring support. Independent recruitment and an explicit separation from assessment or access to help reduce that pressure; willingness cannot be assumed from a returned consent form alone.
- The coding plan should distinguish a reported praise event from the participant's account of whether it helped. A reflexive memo can document the tutor's expectation that praise works and how it might guide prompts or coding.
- Predetermine how contradictory accounts will be retained, compared and discussed, with an audit trail for code changes. Those are proposed safeguards against confirmation bias, not invented interview results or a completed IA discussion.
Common mistake: Excluding criticism because it conflicts with the researcher's teaching beliefs makes the hypothesis determine the evidence.
Marking points
- Separates recruitment/consent from the tutor's evaluative role and offers non-penalised refusal or independent recruitment to reduce power-related pressure.
- Defines praise and perceived helpfulness as distinct codes and includes a reflexive account of the researcher's expectations rather than assuming all praise is effective.
- Retains and analyses negative/contradictory accounts through transparent coding and considers alternative interpretations instead of discarding them.
Examiner tip: Excluding criticism because it conflicts with the researcher's teaching beliefs makes the hypothesis determine the evidence.
- 4.
PREPARATION ONLY: 2027 HL research proposal, not research to conduct. A hypothetical proposal randomises consenting adult community learners to a study-planning prompt or a neutral prompt before a voluntary puzzle task. Participants may stop whenever they wish. The draft records every withdrawal as zero correct answers and claims randomisation will eliminate all bias. Explain why stopping and performance should be distinguished, propose transparent outcome/withdrawal recording with consent safeguards, and evaluate the randomisation claim.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2027: Internal assessment - Format of the report (Research methodology, Data collection, Discussion); Suitability of topics. Applies proposal decision-making and ethical justification to an experimental method at HL for the 2027 cohort. No experiment is conducted and no completed IA, participant outcome or approval is implied.
Worked explanation
- Separate choosing to stop from answering incorrectly. Define beforehand which observed outcomes can be retained under consent and how withdrawn records will be handled; an ethical right to withdraw must not become a disguised performance penalty.
- Even initially comparable groups can yield biased completer comparisons if stopping differs by condition or experience. The discussion should anticipate this mechanism and transparent reporting, not promise that allocation solves post-allocation missingness.
Common mistake: Confusing intention to analyse everyone with permission to invent scores or retain withdrawn data.
Marking points
- Explains that stopping early can leave unmeasured performance and is not automatically zero ability or zero correct on a completed task.
- Plans separate completion status, eligible observed scores and withdrawal/data-removal procedures without inventing missing scores or keeping data contrary to consent.
- Explains that randomisation addresses baseline allocation bias but differential withdrawal can still distort the observed comparison.
Examiner tip: Confusing intention to analyse everyone with permission to invent scores or retain withdrawn data.
- 5.
PREPARATION ONLY: 2027 HL observation proposal. A hypothetical plan compares adult peer-tutoring groups using counts of clarification requests, but proposes observing one group for 15 minutes and another for 45 minutes. Explain the exposure-time problem, propose an operational rate and matched observation plan, and identify why equal rates would still not establish equal learning. Assume overt observation with consent would be sought; do not observe or recruit anyone.
[3 marks] · no calculatorSyllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2027: Internal assessment - Format of the report (observation; methodological justification; Data collection and Discussion). Extends HL 2027 proposal preparation beyond interviews and questionnaires to observation measurement. The method is shared across levels; difficulty is not an invented HL-only IA requirement. No collected evidence is supplied.
Worked explanation
- A raw count mixes behaviour frequency with time at risk of being recorded. Define an explicit clarification request and either use equal-duration comparable windows or divide counts by observed minutes, noting differences in task opportunities.
- Matching duration alone cannot equate task difficulty, number of learners or tutor invitations. Even a well-measured request rate answers a behaviour question; separate valid learning measures would be needed to infer gains.
Common mistake: Interpreting a larger raw count as more help seeking when observation times differ.
Marking points
- Explains that longer observation creates more opportunity to record requests independently of group behaviour.
- Defines requests per observed minute or fixed equal windows with a clear request code, matching task phase and relevant opportunity conditions.
- Explains that requests are a behavioural indicator, not direct evidence of comprehension or learning gains.
Examiner tip: Interpreting a larger raw count as more help seeking when observation times differ.