IB · PSYCH SL

Psychology SL

PREPARATION: Experimental IA design (2026 legacy)

Name: ____________________Date: November 19, 2026
  1. 1.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Legacy IA PREPARATION, not an investigation. A hypothetical plan compares volunteers who choose to study in silence with volunteers who choose music. Identify why this is not an adequate manipulated-variable experiment, redesign the allocation and specify a measurable outcome. No study is to be conducted.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Legacy course

    Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2026, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Group work; Non-experimental studies. Written planning for legacy experimental investigation only; no group investigation, data collection or individual assessed report is delivered.

    Worked explanation

    1. Choice of music condition may track prior habits or memory ability. An independent-groups experiment can randomly assign volunteers to the two researcher-defined conditions while holding list, study duration and recall interval constant.
    2. Count correct words using a predefined scoring rule. This is a methods rehearsal, not a claim of IA eligibility: a real legacy IA also needs an appropriate published theoretical/model basis and teacher-approved ethical design.

    Common mistake: Calling a self-selected comparison random allocation confuses recruitment with experimental assignment.

    Marking points

    • Self-selected conditions confound music with pre-existing participant differences.
    • Manipulates silence versus standardised music and randomly allocates consenting participants to conditions.
    • Defines an outcome such as number of correctly recalled words from a fixed list after a fixed interval.

    Examiner tip: Calling a self-selected comparison random allocation confuses recruitment with experimental assignment.

  2. 2.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Legacy IA PREPARATION. Hypothetical group notes say: 'We will hide the purpose, require classmates to finish, and submit one shared report.' Identify three corrections addressing consent/withdrawal, debriefing and report authorship. Explain why classroom authority matters.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Legacy course

    Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2026, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Group work; Non-experimental studies. Written planning for legacy experimental investigation only; no group investigation, data collection or individual assessed report is delivered.

    Worked explanation

    1. Classmates may feel unable to refuse an apparent class requirement, so recruitment must separate participation from grades and offer a non-penalised alternative. No practical is authorised here.
    2. Explain the purpose as far as possible beforehand and debrief appropriately after an approved task. Collaborate only within the permitted planning/conduct boundary and write an individual report.

    Common mistake: A group investigation does not permit a jointly authored final individual report or compulsory participation.

    Marking points

    • Participation must be voluntary with informed consent and a meaningful right to withdraw, without peer/teacher penalty.
    • Any necessary incomplete disclosure needs teacher ethical review and appropriate debriefing, not blanket concealment.
    • Group planning/conduct is distinguished from each student's independent report; classroom pressure can undermine voluntariness.

    Examiner tip: A group investigation does not permit a jointly authored final individual report or compulsory participation.

  3. 3.

    PREPARATION ONLY. Legacy IA analysis PREPARATION. Entirely invented recall scores, not collected data: silence = 4, 6, 6, 8; music = 3, 5, 5, 7 (correct words). Calculate both means and ranges, interpret the difference cautiously and state what is missing before a statistical conclusion.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Legacy course

    Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2026, Internal assessment: Format of the report; Group work; Non-experimental studies. Written planning for legacy experimental investigation only; no group investigation, data collection or individual assessed report is delivered.

    Worked explanation

    1. Silence: 24/4 = 6 and 8 - 4 = 4. Music: 20/4 = 5 and 7 - 3 = 4; mean difference = 1 correct word.
    2. These very small hypothetical groups overlap. A real report needs justified descriptive and inferential analysis linked to its design, not a fabricated p-value or evidence that the study happened.

    Common mistake: Inventing a significant p-value from descriptive summaries alone confuses observed differences with inferential evidence.

    Marking points

    • Means are 6 and 5 correct words.
    • Ranges are 4 correct words in each group; observed mean difference is 1 correct word favouring silence.
    • Requires design-appropriate inferential analysis/assumptions and sampling context; descriptive difference alone establishes neither significance nor generalisable causation.

    Examiner tip: Inventing a significant p-value from descriptive summaries alone confuses observed differences with inferential evidence.

  4. 4.

    PREPARATION ONLY: legacy experimental IA, not conducted research. A hypothetical random-allocation plan compares two word-encoding instructions. Its DV is 'good memory', and a planning simulation gives nearly everyone 10/10 on an easy list. Specify a reproducible free-recall scoring rule, explain the ceiling problem, and propose a material adjustment that preserves the manipulated encoding instruction. Do not recruit or collect data; an actual IA would require a justified link to published research.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Legacy course

    Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2026: Internal assessment - Format of the report; Non-experimental studies (one manipulated IV and measured DV). Rehearses measurement and control for the legacy SL experimental IA. Planning simulation only; neither an actual investigation nor a completed report or approved replication.

    Worked explanation

    1. For example, award one point for each distinct target word written in 60 seconds, ignoring repeats and awarding none for intrusions. This converts 'good memory' into a reproducible dependent measure.
    2. At 10/10 a genuinely stronger encoding condition may have no measurable headroom. Adjust common materials or delay before the hypothetical main comparison, not difficulty differently across conditions; the simulation is not participant evidence.

    Common mistake: Making only one condition harder to solve a ceiling effect introduces a new confound.

    Marking points

    • Defines correct distinct target words recalled in a fixed period, with an explicit repeat/error rule.
    • Explains that scores near the maximum leave little room to distinguish the encoding conditions.
    • Proposes a harder but matched list or fixed longer retention interval applied equally to both conditions, retaining encoding instruction as the single IV.

    Examiner tip: Making only one condition harder to solve a ceiling effect introduces a new confound.

  5. 5.

    PREPARATION ONLY: legacy IA analysis reasoning. A hypothetical independent-groups experiment randomly allocates consenting adults to semantic or visual encoding instructions, measuring the number of correctly recalled words. No data are supplied. Write a non-directional research hypothesis and corresponding population null hypothesis. Explain why a future difference between sample means alone would not establish statistical significance. Do not invent a test result or conduct the experiment.

    [3 marks] · no calculator

    Course scope: Legacy course

    Syllabus placement evidence: Psychology examiner instructions 2026: Internal assessment - Format of the report (descriptive and inferential statistics). Prepares legacy SL experimental-IA analysis without replacing its actual investigation, published-research basis or inferential analysis. Not the proposal-only 2027 IA.

    Worked explanation

    1. The research hypothesis concerns a difference without predicting which instruction gives higher recall. The null concerns the population comparison, not a requirement that the observed sample means be exactly equal.
    2. Sampling variation can produce unequal means even under a null model. Select and justify an inferential analysis using the actual design and distribution when data exist; no p-value or significance statement is possible here.

    Common mistake: Defining the null as every participant remembering the same number of words.

    Marking points

    • States a non-directional difference in population mean correct recall between the two encoding conditions.
    • States the corresponding null as no population mean difference, rather than identical scores for every individual.
    • Explains that an appropriate inferential procedure needs data, variability, sample size and design/assumption checks, not just unequal sample means.

    Examiner tip: Defining the null as every participant remembering the same number of words.