Economics HL
Commentary Evidence and Evaluation
- 1.
Preparation only. A learner plans to write on 19 October 2026. Their provisional portfolio uses a microeconomics article from Source A and a macroeconomics article from Source B. They propose a global-economy article from Source A dated 1 August 2025. Identify two problems and propose a compliant selection strategy without supplying or writing the assessed commentary.
[4 marks] · no calculator - 2.
Preparation only. A hypothetical news scenario reports policy-rate cuts during a recession: factories have spare capacity but lenders report weak loan demand. Develop a short-run growth mechanism, a limitation, and an evidence-based conditional judgement. Identify one quantity you would seek in the learner's eventual real news article. This is not a submitted commentary.
[4 marks] · no calculator - 3.
Preparation only. A hypothetical report says that unemployment fell from 8% to 6% after a training subsidy. A draft calls this 'proof the subsidy created every new job' and discusses only employers. Explain two weaknesses and propose two specific improvements, including a stakeholder perspective. No causal effect estimate has been supplied.
[4 marks] · no calculator - 4.
Preparation only; no genuine news article is supplied. A fictional economy's currency depreciates. For the first month, assume export prices in domestic currency, export volumes, foreign-currency import prices and import volumes remain fixed by contracts. Importers nevertheless pay more domestic currency for those imports. An analyst calls the worsening trade balance proof that depreciation can never help. Explain the initial result, outline how later volume responses might improve the balance, and give two conditions or evidence checks needed for a J-curve interpretation. Use change as the lens and do not write an assessed commentary.
[4 marks] · no calculator - 5.
Preparation only. In a fictional fiscal-policy scenario, government purchases rise by $40 million. Marginal propensities to save, tax and import out of additional income are 0.20, 0.15 and 0.25. Assume these leakages are constant, prices are fixed, spare capacity is available and no other autonomous spending changes in the initial model. Calculate the Keynesian multiplier and predicted total increase in real GDP. Then explain why a loan-financed programme could produce a smaller increase through crowding out and identify one relevant evidence check for a future real-article commentary. Use intervention as the lens; these are not observed results or a completed IA.
[4 marks] - 6.
Commentary preparation only. A fictional common-access fish stock contains 1000 tonnes at the start of a year. For this one-year model, natural net regeneration before harvest is fixed at 200 tonnes, with no other inflows or losses. Twelve boats each plan to catch 25 tonnes. Calculate the closing stock under these plans and under an enforced total catch limit of 200 tonnes. Explain why each boat may still prefer a higher private catch even when combined plans reduce the stock. Evaluate the claim that the limit guarantees a sustainable fishery indefinitely, and identify one evidence check through a sustainability lens. Do not treat the invented model as real ecological findings or write an assessed commentary.
[5 marks]